First, my answer to the question I asked: I believe Mafia killed Zherog because that gave us very little info, since he wasn't posting much. Remember that the next time you want to lynch someone because said person is not very active. That's exactly what Mafia wants.




I think I made my night target pretty clear in the post I revealed I'm the cop. If you still want that laid out to you, I have no problem saying that my target was C_K. The fact that his post pattern changed a lot since my claim makes me believe I'm looking at the right place, on top of everything else I already said in the claim post.



I'm not going to pretend that's not a possibility. I thought about that when I was posting my claim. Still, by lynching me, you guys have a greater chance of lynching a Town than a Mafia (the chance is actually 100% to lynch a Town, but no one besides me or the Mafia has any ways to know that for sure).

Although I don't agree with your reasoning, I do acknowledge that lynching me right now has its merits, even if for a different reason. Right now, we have a dance between the Goblins and our Doctor. If our guy knows Mafia will roleblock me until I'm alive, he's free to save whoever he wants. Mafia can try to think ahead and kill me instead of blocking me, but there's always the fear that I'm the doc's target and I'm free to look at my target. If you think that's a bad spot for Town to be, lynching me might be a good idea. I don't agree that it's a bad spot to be for Town, but wouldn't fault anyone for wanting my head (for that reason specifically).



I'm quoting Confused here, but the message goes to the other players with the same point too (namely Neo and Garren). You're all basically saying I didn't need to claim because Shock was already a dead man. You guys are kidding, right? Are we even reading the same game? Go back and read Day 2. Aside from me, there was actually ZERO pressure over Shock. People were all over the place, pointing fingers to Freddeh for no reason and making posts like this:



and this:



while I was forcing Shock and C_K was desperately trying to shift focus. If that's not proof that Shock was far from death, I don't know what is. I'm not saying that you have to believe in my words, but try to look at the situation from my angle. I know Shock is a goblin, but pretty much everyone is looking somewhere else. There's a guy asking me questions that, by that point, probably knows that I have a power role, and I have a pretty big suspicion that he's Mafia. To make things worse, I wont be available to talk for almost a week. TL;DR: I'm dead, and there's a good chance that my findings will be ignored after my death. In that situation, I rather improve my chances of living while gambling with the presence of a roleblocker (that now I have confirmation it's present, even though you guys don't have), specially when you consider that I'm now holding the roleblocker with me. One could argue that I played poorly when I was pushing for Shock without exposing myself (even though Zherog stated that he thought I was doing well during that time, and now Mafia killed him. Coincidence?), but I still think claiming there was correct.

Saying that Shock was a dead man before the claim when he clearly wasn't made me a lot more suspicious about those 3. When you factor that I was already suspicious about Neo, you know what I'm thinking right now. Still, I'm not voting on him, and I'll get to that in a moment.

First, I want to talk about the wild card in this game: Silly. First, playing with him is kind of impossible due to the amount of bad puns I want to make On a more serious comment, he voted for Garren on Day 2, and I want to hear more about that, and if anything changed for day 3. I also want to hear from him what he thinks about a lot of things (basically the whole game, since he was a little late to the party), but the vote for Garren and how that translates to day 3 is the most pressing subject.