I think we are forgetting that lily's capabilities. She, as a Planeswalker, represents all black archetypes, except for life loss-life gain. She has her own mind hacks. Not necessarily hacks, but mostly just driving them insane. Also, I think she has some pretty serious non-zombie summons on her hands. In agents, she summons a death angel. like, common.

Well, not common. That was a trump card. The spirits and specters were her common. She even threw together some shades, and THOSE are definitely something to be concerned with.
She even managed a vampire, though it was distinctly implied that was a different sort of experience for her and it took a little finagling to get it to follow orders.

I think he meant "come on" rather than "common," but I could well be wrong.

You know me too well.

ANYWAY this one seemed to have come to a close. Lilliana has taken the win. Suggestions are allowed.

Ashiok vs Tibalt in a torture off.

Kamahl vs people who like their torsos in one piece.

Isn't Kamahl Fights Everyone already the plot line of the Odyssey block?

Always bet on Jace, the Mind Sculptor.

I was REALLY hoping that someone wouldn't say that. Thank you.

Nicol Bolas would beat them all.

Consensus seems to be Lili > Garruk > Jace = Ajani > Chandra.

Can the next one be Rashida Scalebane vs Sarkhan Vol?

ooh, that's a good one.