Hey thanks for the feedback
I'll explain my reasoning and we can figure out if I should tweak my strategy at all. So on the flip I'm ahead, we can be comfortable with that. I'm OOP so I absolutely need to develop and protect my checking my range. You know this already, otherwise I get run over every time I check.
Now when you protect your check range you can't just check raise or check fold, you need a check call range too or you get led into the turn when you check call with nothing. So I want to fully balance my check range with a reasonable mix of check raise, check call and check fold
Now top pair with garbage kicker and straight draw on a coordinated board struck me as a check call but you could be right that it might be check raise. If I had top pair and flush draw, I would check raise or bet for SURE. So I think the sequence of 876 scares me that I might be check raising into a straight
Ok so that's the flop. Now you saw I should bet the turn where is a fair observation but don't forget she bet the flop so I'm planning on check calling here again but it goes check check what's ch is fine since I don't have a monster or anything
It's the huge bet on the river where ch screwed me up and I'm glad you agree that my fold is okay but I'm still not convinced
Interesting hand that shows how brutal it is to be OOP
I'm not rejecting my your advice btw, I just want to have a discussion so you understand what my passive looking play is doing
1. If you are trying to protect your checking range, then it's a check-raise spot always. You aren't strong enough to trap with such a mediocre hand. Any random big card hoses you. If you are checking to balance, then you should be check-raising. Anything less means that you are converting a made hand into a drawing hand, which is bad. Your problem is that you are balancing with a hand that is not polarized at all. I.E. you have no idea where you are in the hand when like 60% of the deck comes out on the turn. You can check/raise flop and fold to pretty much any raise back to you safely without a ton of history with this player.
2. Good news, you got about the only card that reasonably changes nothing for the hand! Your hand, while still only medium strength, is likely ahead of most hands that call a preflop raise and then donk the flop with position. Of course, there are a bunch of weird hands, like 99 or TT that you could be behind and this problem is exacerbated by the fact your flop play does nothing to establish any range whatsoever, but we can assume that if we were ahead flop, we're still ahead turn. So why check now? What is gained? Check/call is always worse than simply leading yourself if your goal is getting value. It protects against bad rivers (again, there are ALOT of them) and it lets you extract value from hands that were simply betting with position on the flop. Checking here is pretty awful unless you have your opponent pegs as a nit, in which case I guess check/fold is fine (again, this is a problem created by the passive flop play).
3. Calling the river would be a very Vert play (I'm a laggy player with a hero-call complex) and it's going to be wrong more times than right. In a rebuy tourney, players are more likely to make these types of calls, which a reg should know and would be likely to try to exploit. Further, overbet-shipping a bluff into a very straight-heavy board is all kinds of terrible, so I am going to discount that option heavily. Anything going for value is ahead of you, so just fold.
4. All the info you have given me leads me to believe this is not a massive nit (reg, semi-pro, in a REBUY tourney, no less). Therefore, playing so passively with a mid-strength hand is a way to bleed money.
I feel pretty confident in my line of thinking here and yes, you should re-evaluate your line on the flop and ask yourself what you are balancing there for. (that's ignoring that balancing is almost never worth it vs. people you don't play with alot, because you'll find yourself in a leveling game against someone who is playing a more logical, rote style and you will do nothing but level yourself)
tl/dr: change your flop play and all these crappy spots become much more straight-forward.