Laurentus - Ok, honestly? There's no way you come in-thread catching up but not realizing KoD is dead lmfao, twas kinda funny. Could be a way to generate fluff/CWAC, but it came across as you legit derping. Also, if your dayvig is real I'm pretty confident we can pretty much clear your slot, because despite it happening SOMETIMES, it's a really strong role for scum to have and I don't think they'd use this early in the phase, but rather at the end to mess a tie and take two townies or something similar since we're likely at MyLo. If you're just bluffing, oh, well, you'll still be a bit high up because of the derp, lmfao.
Dusky- I don't remember much, they contributed a bit but it was mainly poking some members which comes as a bit lazy. I don't remember their playstyle much, but I think they play like this as both alignments, so it's not really memorable? Did some poking that I liked, specially regarding my role WHICH NOONE SEEMED TO CARE, but that was it, it felt a bit shallow, but honestly it was better than most of the players so far. Voted early in Mongoose wagon, and late on Rag's wagon; the former makes sense as scum, but the latter feels extremely unnecessary for scum to do, kinda like the same logic as the one I mentioned about Dark during D2. Overall, no strong feelings towards this slot.
Skystone - Made the killing vote on Goose, completely pointless vote on Rag. Looking back, the vote on Goose doesn't look as bad since both wagons were town, so scum didn't really have to step forward unless they had a reason to go after Goose first. Overall fine slot but kinda lacking
Silver - Beefed up with Fext a bit, said something about not making promises and killing Lau, vanished. Did they vote during any of the phases?
Hello World - Who? Literally nothing impactful came out of them so far, completely ambiguous and if anything slightly scummy. I need/want more content. Could be a problematic slot if it made to LyLo regardless of alignment.
Fext - Overall negative feelings about this slot. Seems to be contributing somewhat, but so far it's been quite an amount of bluffing and kinda throwing shade randomly at people. Has been somewhat assuming the role of townleading, but pushed towards two wagons that ended up being major power roles. One thing they have going for them is that the bluff that kinda fearmongered some players into not breaking their promise. The issue is, if Fext is scum, and one of the people affected by the fake role is also scum, then they could break promises behind the scenes and we wouldn't be aware of it (I think? are broken promises made public? No, right?). I also don't like how you made a pretty strong promise (although not necessarily binding as Skystone had just explained
A few extra thoughts
Skystone likely doesn't start early in the game throwing shade at silver as scum, in retrospect I should've pushed Silver to see his (Sky's) reaction.
Silver does not publicly get mad at Fext if they're partners.
Actually, I have a lot of thoughts about your wall.
How does the result of Fext's pushes matter in the least, beyond either scum or town dying? Even if we assume that mafia have a role blocker, that doesn't matter on D1 when we lynched the cop. I feel like, if anything, the nature of his D2, where he spent all of D1 white-knighting the D2 lynch only to join the wagon without adequately prodding in different directions, is the better scum case.
I don't like your Dusky read, either. As scum, it's typically harder to vote early, especially with compelling reasons, and far easier to just join a wagon you know is going to be Town. Also worth noting that Dusky's D1 vote was the first on Goose, and considering how we can't change votes here, it's not unreasonable to think they might have took a gamble by placing a vote on a wagon they thought might not taking off, only for it to actually do so and watch on in horror as it did. That psychology would actually kinda explain the D2 action of not wanting to risk an early vote again. I... have my own reasons for liking this slot, but your reasons are bad.
Your vote analysis is just baffling, consistently. Like, if scum knows that both wagons are not scum, but still need to be around and active, especially in this environment that is so hostile to lurkers, they literally have nothing to lose by placing their vote on any of the wagons. You say the slot is completely lacking outside of that but then still have them as your 3rd highest town. Why am I holstering my shot, again?
Apart from the vote, there is functionally nothing different fypov about Hello World and Sky, so again, just yuck.
And then you shade the one slot that has actually dared to do much as your top scum. Despite previously saying you liked them. Just blindly shading the FPS doesn't do anything for me, either. Show me why the motive behind the fake claim is scummy, then we have something to talk about.
Login
Register
Card Search
NGAWiki
Search
I have my eyes on you. 