Hmmm, I’ll take that as food for thought for now until we can hear from KoD, and CL I suppose.

Unvote

Ok, listen.

I know how to count.

15 1/2 and 13 1/2 total hours for inventory over two days.

Guess what this guy is doing?

Also Goose isn't The One simply because he clearly didn't read the rules about having one and only one vote with which to utilize.

That means someone else here is The One. Eh? Eh? *Elbows Arrgh.*

Still counting?

No, I was freed like 2 hours ago.

Now I'm just existing.

Also, I got town on CL so at this point sup.

Alright, I'm rested up a bit better.

So yesterday Zinger had scum on me (assuming he didn't get scum on Tevish since he used the exact same statement first on him than on me and seemingly was insistent on me). I believe CL also got scum on me as well. I got town on myself.

Goose got a nil result on Dusky (Dusky being a jester and all). Then he got town on CL. I, too, got CL as town on this round of investigations.

Arrgh targeted me for a town result on the second round of investigations. On the first round he got uhhhhhh *checks notes*


Aaarrrgh wrote:
My interpretation of his post is that he investigated KoD and got a scum result.

@Zinger: if I'm wrong about your investigation, please call me trash.

Zinger wrote:
Thank you Mary-Jane Watson.


Interesting. Way to be obfuscate.




Tevish got guilty on Zinger (and Zinger wasn't the one). Arrgh got town on himself.

That should be all the results thus far.

That being said, it doesn't help us much as we already know the killer is hiding among us four though as what is the question. What we can assume is that Tevish was either the paranoid or insane player given his guilty result on Zinger and Zinger turning up as not The One (I'm assuming The One to be the Krampus even though we're not in the Xmas Rumble so obv this is going to be horrible).

Zinger, too, claimed a "scum"/guilty result either on me or Tevish. Maybe because his responses were not all that clear. In any event, both Zinger and Tevish take up the insane/paranoid roles given their results (or potential results). Depending on how you look at it, if Tevish was the paranoid one and Zinger the insane one, then I'm clear given his result and assuming you believe Zinger targeted me and got the scum result. That's about the only noteworthy piece of information that can be pulled from that mess, unless you don't believe Zinger targeted me in which case it's open ended anyway which isn't too far from square one.

At this point that means concretely that one of the three of us (thus far) is lying about their result/s. Strictly speaking, none of us can be paranoid or insane since those two roles are taken by Zinger and Tevish. If this looks weird, it's because I've been excluding CL up to this point and focusing exclusively on us with the strictly town resutls. Arrgh with town on himself and me, me with town on myself and CL, and Goose with a nil on Dusky and town on CL strictly means that one of us is lying as we can't all be nice/naive.

I'm going to keep CL to the side for the moment.

Both Arrgh's and my first result on similar in that we targeted ourselves and got town on ourselves. Both Goose's and my second results are similar in that we both targeted CL and got town. Note that Arrgh's second result was on me as town which flies in the face of both scum results (Zinger and CL assuming you take Zinger's investigation to be on me based on his responses). Of the three of us, Goose is the only one to receive a result that isn't exactly compatible with the known standard sanities. After all, everything we know is still wrong so what is to say that we're not dealing with a random sanity? Despite the existence of a jester, you'd think naive would still produce a nice/innocent result regardless of the role, right? At least that is what I would assume; however, it's possible, though I wouldn't say equally possible to the existence of a random sanity, that the jester naturally has a chance to return a nil result to whoever investigates it. If that were the case, then we would still be at the beginning of trying to untangle this.

So far we've got two assumptions that can advance our state: assuming Zinger targeted me and was insane (no proof of his sanity) and assuming Goose is a random sanity due to the nil result on Jester Dusky (no conclusive proof that the Jester simply has a chance to return a nil result).

If I take just the random sanity assumption as truth, that would mean CL is The One. Why? Because of the nil result, which doesn't fit the standard sanities, Goose is a random sanity which leaves naive/nice with Arrgh and I (in any combination) while CL is the ***ONLY*** player left that has a guilty/scum result on me despite Tevish and Zinger both having scum results and both being dead (which means they take up the two sanities paranoid and insane).

So, based on that, I would conclude CL to be The One; however, everything we know is still wrong, right? Well, I have no **** clue what it is I'm doing, and I'm still at square one if CL is being honest about his result. I mean, Zinger was Peter Parker or something with two different results potentially if the whole, "You're trash, Brock," is supposed to be an indication of his result/s. Nothing, as previously stated by me, exactly clears that up for sure, unless the thank you he gave to Arrgh was meant as a , "Yes, you're right," despite Arrgh specifically asking to be called trash if he was wrong about his interpretations of Zinger's words.



So hey, I got nothing except my fingers which are still capable of wallsmithing.

I'm pretty sure "You're trash, Brock. was Zinger's vote. He indicated his result by quoting someone else with the same result and saying "Double the money".

I never thought of it that way.

I got scum on myself.

I went back to verify what you were saying, Arrgh, and Zinger's vote did, indeed, land on me despite him "voting" for Tevish first.

That said I think I've got it kind of worked out. Granted the nil result Goose had was on Jester Dusky, it would be able to account for why three of us have nice results as opposed to a single scum result with the exception of CL.

As for CL, well, two players that obviously were not The One died with scum results given out. So either CL is The One, or everything I know is still wrong.

Damn jesters.

That say’s it all.

A little less than 23 hours remain. At this rate goose will singlehandly lynch KoD.

Much power. Such awe.

From my perspective it seems most likely that we're looking at either CL or KoD, so I guess I'm ok with the KoD lynch. In fact, I'll bite the bullet and actually take an active part in this.

vote: KoD

What, exactly, is your reasoning there Arrgh? Because per your own point concerning Zinger, there's much more likely a chance that I'm town as opposed to you or Goose or CL.

Alright, classic Arrgh over here not engaging.

Well, I'm two minds about this. Based on what I said earlier. CL seems like he'd be the prime choice to be The One; however, Arrgh over here is seeminglybopen wolfing via jumping with Goose onto me after having gone out of his way to initially be like hey, think about it. Clearly there is no actual groundwork here that Arrgh is working off of. Add to that his earlier assessment regarding Zinger, assuming a standard sanity, makes his current approach boggling at best, instascum at worse.

Goose, for what it is worth, I think you're instant action upon voting me was just you, as town, being wrong but going with what you thought was good.

CL, I want to make a deal with you. I know I vigged your face off and that I have kinda maintained that you may be scum here, but Arrgh is acting like it. Let's make nice and vote him together ok?

Vote: Arrgh

Looks like he didn't want to make nice. At 2-1, KoD is lynched. He was not the one.

Send in your night roles. You have 48 or until they're all in.

All targets are in. No deaths to report. Go forth and finish this.