Well, you're wrong.

I'm not saying it was the optimal scum play, but it is the only play that fits the facts.

Quoting your PM amounts to claiming your alignment. Hence, upon review, that promise might not be binding in practical fact. Or, would you like to propose that we can solve the entire game merely by posting our PMs and pinky-promising that we used only those abilities?

The facts of the matter are that you admit that you targeted KoD; you professed that you 'might' have caused his missing pinky; you interpreted yourself as having a role-block when we know that a role-block ought to be the opposite ability; and you went missing Day 3, which allowed you to 'miss' either voting for Aaarrrgh or voting for someone else while he flipped town.

Perhaps even more concerning, you still haven't commented on the game -- you defended yourself from suspicion, then left it at that.

So: If you aren't scum, then tell us who is.

i'm not sure sky as scum votes arrgh yesterday

given that it was 3 scum and 3 to lynch there's a pretty reasonable shot that they could try to push through a somewhat last-minute wagon on a town for the win, and if not then just not vote and go for nl > push a mistake from town to win in lylo with more votes (proportionally)
no defense of arrgh indicates that either he was abandoned or there were no good counterwagons or his team is completely afk
i could *possibly* see an argument for his getting bussed but we know kod is town and i know i'm town which would literally only leave sky and i don't think he makes the bus play when just letting him live and then going into lylo is both easier and safer

im comfortable using that to clear sky, and with tevish also cleared that leaves us with 2/3 of naga, monster, and mongoose
of these we have the least on mongoose, which i think makes him the worst lynch of the 3
naga i think we have the night 1 and 3 targets but not night 2 i think? which i'm actually a little interested to hear
given monster's target list i'm not entirely convinced, but if we have a better target then i'm willing to wait on that

Vote: Naga

For all the reasons listed above. Just didn't want to give scum the chance to hammer us early.

well

we haven't lost, i guess
may as well guarantee it?
vote: naga

And so another day barely creeps by...

Vote Count 4.Final

Amber: Monster
Naga: Tevish, Skystone, Amber

Naga is lynched. He was Let's Keep It Honest.

It is now night, 48 hours till deadline.

As dawn once again breaks the horizon, you gather once more. Perhaps for the last time? But certainly not for Amber, as she's sleeping in, peacefully caressed by a pool of blood.

Amber is dead. She was I Betray You BECAUSE I Love You.

With Four Alive, it's three to majority, and two to Lynch. You have 96 hours.

Tevish, Skystone, and Mongoose.

Two of you are scum, and one is Town.

The optimist in me wants to believe Tevish is Town, but I don't think we'd be this far up ****'s creek without a paddle if that were true. No, I think I am the last remaining active Town. Mongoose is MIA, and he's my only ally and my only chance of beating the Tevish/Skystone team.

I see no point in arguing these interpretations of the facts with my enemies, so if you're going to kill me and win the game for Mafia, make it quick.

To my ghost townmates who are watching in silence, I'm sorry. I tried.

Mongoose, if you are still around and reading this, please sop lurking. Your town needs you.

Vote: Tevish

That's majority and game. I will post the dirty deets after work but your winners are Monster, Ex, Aaarrrgh, Skystone, and Ex.

gg.

Sorry, was less active at the end that I should have been. I think I had smoked out the scum but wasn't sure and did nothing about it.

Should have done in monster rather than letting a countered "doc" with the world's worst suspect list live to the end.

GG, Town was phoning it in this game. I feel like KoD and I were the only ones pulling any weight for Town.

Tevish, step your game up. xD First off, fighting with me over semantics on Day 1 re: Rag was a big waste of time, and then to watch you make it to the last day only to buddy up with scum was painful. All the "should have done in monster sooner" in the world wouldn't have saved you from Skystone, whom you had cleared because you couldn't fathom a world where he bussed Aaarrrgh to fool you.

I don't know why scum bussed Aaarrrgh. They would have won sooner if they hadn't.

And mongoose, you let Monster tell you what to do? Sheesh.

Congrats mafia!
True team work prevailed.

Sad I died so early but the little time I had was fun.

Actually, it's easy for me to point fingers and say others didn't do much, but in hindsight, I didn't do much to help town either.

GG comrades.


Amber and Tevish both post late at night, so if I vote with Monster and either shows up, then they still kill Aaarrrgh (or, at best, we tiebreak) but also solve me in the process. There's no point in taking that risk when I'm firmly embedded as town in the eyes of the living.

Plus, "I can't be mafia -- I prevented scum from winning" is a fairly ironclad defense overall.

i mean it worked, so yeah

ggs friends (: