Is it Torrent of Souls?

Traitor's Roar

20) Is it a creature? NO
19) Is it a one-color, Modern-legal card? NO
18) Is it exactly one color? NO
17) Is it colorless? NO
16) Is it blue? NO
15) Is it Black? YES
14) Is it Red? YES
13) Is it an Instant or an Enchantment? NO
12) Does it have a CMC of 5 or greater? YES
11) Is it a rare or a mythic rare? NO
10) Is it Fumarole? NO
9) Is it Plague Spores? NO
8) Is it Torrent of Souls? NO

Wrong Guesses
Untamed Hunger
Mystic Veil
Warpath
Maze's End
Glimpse the Unthinkable
Rakdos's Return
Deathreap Ritual
Fervent Charge
Demonspine Whip
Grave Upheaval
Morgue Burst
Skull Rend
Traitor's Roar

Is it Void from the Timeshifted printing?

20) Is it a creature? NO
19) Is it a one-color, Modern-legal card? NO
18) Is it exactly one color? NO
17) Is it colorless? NO
16) Is it blue? NO
15) Is it Black? YES
14) Is it Red? YES
13) Is it an Instant or an Enchantment? NO
12) Does it have a CMC of 5 or greater? YES
11) Is it a rare or a mythic rare? NO
10) Is it Fumarole? NO
9) Is it Plague Spores? NO
8) Is it Torrent of Souls? NO
7) Is it Void from the Timeshifted printing? NO

Wrong Guesses
Untamed Hunger
Mystic Veil
Warpath
Maze's End
Glimpse the Unthinkable
Rakdos's Return
Deathreap Ritual
Fervent Charge
Demonspine Whip
Grave Upheaval
Morgue Burst
Skull Rend
Traitor's Roar

All answers ARE Correct.

Is it from a yet-to-be released set?

20) Is it a creature? NO
19) Is it a one-color, Modern-legal card? NO
18) Is it exactly one color? NO
17) Is it colorless? NO
16) Is it blue? NO
15) Is it Black? YES
14) Is it Red? YES
13) Is it an Instant or an Enchantment? NO
12) Does it have a CMC of 5 or greater? YES
11) Is it a rare or a mythic rare? NO
10) Is it Fumarole? NO
9) Is it Plague Spores? NO
8) Is it Torrent of Souls? NO
7) Is it Void from the Timeshifted printing? NO
6) Is it from a yet-to-be released set? NO

Wrong Guesses
Untamed Hunger
Mystic Veil
Warpath
Maze's End
Glimpse the Unthinkable
Rakdos's Return
Deathreap Ritual
Fervent Charge
Demonspine Whip
Grave Upheaval
Morgue Burst
Skull Rend
Traitor's Roar

All answers ARE Correct. It is likely that the gatherer search term generated by at least one answer is leading you wrong.

Is it 1996 World Champion?

20) Is it a creature? NO
19) Is it a one-color, Modern-legal card? NO
18) Is it exactly one color? NO
17) Is it colorless? NO
16) Is it blue? NO
15) Is it Black? YES
14) Is it Red? YES
13) Is it an Instant or an Enchantment? NO
12) Does it have a CMC of 5 or greater? YES
11) Is it a rare or a mythic rare? NO
10) Is it Fumarole? NO
9) Is it Plague Spores? NO
8) Is it Torrent of Souls? NO
7) Is it Void from the Timeshifted printing? NO
6) Is it from a yet-to-be released set? NO
5) Is it 1996 World Champion? NO (Too blue)

Wrong Guesses
Untamed Hunger
Mystic Veil
Warpath
Maze's End
Glimpse the Unthinkable
Rakdos's Return
Deathreap Ritual
Fervent Charge
Demonspine Whip
Grave Upheaval
Morgue Burst
Skull Rend
Traitor's Roar

All answers ARE Correct. It is likely that the gatherer search term generated by at least one answer is leading you wrong.

Does it have both a and an in its mana cost?

20) Is it a creature? NO
19) Is it a one-color, Modern-legal card? NO
18) Is it exactly one color? NO
17) Is it colorless? NO
16) Is it blue? NO
15) Is it Black? YES
14) Is it Red? YES
13) Is it an Instant or an Enchantment? NO
12) Does it have a CMC of 5 or greater? YES
11) Is it a rare or a mythic rare? NO
10) Is it Fumarole? NO
9) Is it Plague Spores? NO
8) Is it Torrent of Souls? NO
7) Is it Void from the Timeshifted printing? NO
6) Is it from a yet-to-be released set? NO
5) Is it 1996 World Champion? NO (Too blue)
4) Does it have both a and an in its mana cost? YES

Wrong Guesses
Untamed Hunger
Mystic Veil
Warpath
Maze's End
Glimpse the Unthinkable
Rakdos's Return
Deathreap Ritual
Fervent Charge
Demonspine Whip
Grave Upheaval
Morgue Burst
Skull Rend
Traitor's Roar

OK, I figured out your trick...

Is it Toil // Trouble?

20) Is it a creature? NO
19) Is it a one-color, Modern-legal card? NO
18) Is it exactly one color? NO
17) Is it colorless? NO
16) Is it blue? NO
15) Is it Black? YES
14) Is it Red? YES
13) Is it an Instant or an Enchantment? NO
12) Does it have a CMC of 5 or greater? YES
11) Is it a rare or a mythic rare? NO
10) Is it Fumarole? NO
9) Is it Plague Spores? NO
8) Is it Torrent of Souls? NO
7) Is it Void from the Timeshifted printing? NO
6) Is it from a yet-to-be released set? NO
5) Is it 1996 World Champion? NO (Too blue)
4) Does it have both a and an in its mana cost? YES
3) Is it Toil//Trouble? NO

Wrong Guesses
Untamed Hunger
Mystic Veil
Warpath
Maze's End
Glimpse the Unthinkable
Rakdos's Return
Deathreap Ritual
Fervent Charge
Demonspine Whip
Grave Upheaval
Morgue Burst
Skull Rend
Traitor's Roar

Is it Pain // Suffering?

YES!

... which guessing for it seems to have caused.

OK, ready

To take a page out of your book...

Is it a one-color, vintage-legal card?

Kaalia of the Vast

Questions
20) Is it a one-color, vintage-legal card? YES

Incorrect Guess
Kaalia of the Vast[/quote]

Is it a creature?

Kaysa

Questions
20) Is it a one-color, vintage-legal card? YES
19) Is it a creature? YES

Incorrect Guess
Kaalia of the Vast
Kaysa

Is it blue or white?

Skirk Alarmist