Black Barney
2 - Cucho
0.5 - Barney
0 - Nomad
2 - Soup
2 - DCG
Total: 6.5

DCG-MTG - First
6 - Cucho
5.5 - Barney
1.5 - Nomad
6 - Soup
5.5 - DCG
Total: 24.5

Mowie666 - Second
0.5 - Cucho
5.5 - Barney
5 - Nomad
4 - Soup
5.5 - DCG
Total: 20.5

CardboardNomad
3 - Cucho
4 - Barney
6 - Nomad
0 - Soup
1 - DCG
Total: 14

Haven_PT
0.5 - Cucho
2.5 - Barney
3 - Nomad
1 - Soup
3 - DCG
Total: 10

Cucho Lambreta
2 - Cucho
2.5 - Barney
4 - Nomad
3 - Soup
4 - DCG
Total: 15.5

TheFlakyMage
5 - Cucho
0.5 - Barney
1.5 - Nomad
5 - Soup
0 - DCG
Total: 12

Upset! I was sure Mowie had that. Congrats DCG!

Congratulation (singular) DCG! You're finally out of the doghouse for that first contest with the Sly Requisitioner. Well done.

Also, shame, Barney! Shaaaame!

I think the ultimate winner and the worst loser should pick the next pair of cards to break.

Hehe, I like it. Epic or epic fail. But nothing for mediocrity.

But... do we really want to give Barney that much power? You know how he gets. The maniacal laughter, the petty demands, the constant verbal abuse towards his “cretinous minions”... and that’s just when he gets ahold of the tv remote.

Ehh...if we're going to do this in a systematic way, I'd say the popular vote should get the second choice. Mowie's was the deck of the people, after all. If we followed first and worst, we'd potentially be rewarding decks like Methodical Construction - I think we can all agree that's ethically wrong.

Winningiest and most popular decks pick the two cards perhaps?

For now I'm going to stick with my original plan of letting the winner pick one card and then adding a 2nd complementary one at my discretion. So far I think I like just having one card a little more, anyway.

Speaking of winners picking cards... how long you gonna keep us in suspense?

Congrats DCG!

Ugh can’t believe I got last place! I make a better judge I think. The two decks that DCG and I scored higher chest ending up being the top two

Nice Victory DCG!! You even got a single congrat from Soup - that's quite something-
It's beyond doubt that your deck was the best this time , 5 judges actually played all decks and you got 24,5 /30, Haunted dead+ GY recurtion + cheap madness were indeed Cathartic reunion BFF.
On to the next one.

Congrats DCG! From the decks I tested, it trully had the best run.
Sorry I didn't get around to testing all the decks, but between 50+ hour work week, family life and sleeping, Duels time was way too short for 7 decks... Maybe I should just go Barney style.
Anyway, if I can't come up with anything good next time, I'll skip submitting and save you all a good bit of time.
So, what's next?

Yeah, I don’t know what I was thinking. Remember the last time we were nice to Barney? The carpets in my foyer still smell like processed cheese slices!

This was fun, congrats DCG. How does one go about picking a card for this? I would have no idea..

Barney off topic, do you have the decklist that you won the first tourney with (the thopters/aether grid one), or was I on hallucinogens?

DCG what was that Flaky variant you were playing last night, Tutelage in place of Titi? Looked interesting.

And what's the pick? The natives are growing restless.

Think I did:
-2 TitI
-2 Languish
-2 Fling
-1 Manticore

+2 Yahenni's Expertise
+1 Pull from Tomorrow
+1 Tutelage
+1 Cruel Reality
+1 Kefnet
+1 Kalitas

TitI never seemed to get there, so it got the axe. Diversified the win cons so it's harder for Opp to answer all of them. Single Tutelage provides nice inevitability. Think I went 10-3 last night? 3 wins off stream as well. Could still make some adjustments, but 13-3 isn't bad.

Mulling over a couple options, I'll pick tonight.

Mowie, that was Coverts deck. I’ll try to find it

Found it!!

viewtopic.php?f=38&t=13012&p=398565#p398557

I'm 10-0 with Mowies knock off!!! I looove it!
I also love thopters I got a very competitive one in my library. We can exchange notes

Mowie im now 20-3 with Reaper. Loving it.

Hmm. Was leaning towards Vizier of Tumbling Sands but, on further research, it doesn't look like we have many compelling tap-activated abilities. Still some cute interactions available, but meh.

Also noticed that no white card had broken into the lineup yet, so here we go - Long Road Home is the pick. Good for ETBs/Revolt, against tokens/auras, and saving creatures from removal/wipes. Should be open ended enough.

White weenie here we go! That and good ol' blink decks.

Ok... at least I haven't got a single deck that uses that abortion...
Flaky what say you?! Are pumping the crap?

Yay I like cards that frustrate Control players

I won’t be submitting a deck this time around