@Sl33p:
I get where you're coming from, I'm long past the "internet atheist" days of pointing out religion's inconsistencies and damaging impact on what I saw as the progress of society. Now however, whilst I still have no belief I'm any more than worm food when the candle goes out, I can see the appeal of hoping there's nothing once your thoughts stop. Its just a fear of mortality, the fear of nothingness, literal nothingness that we cannot comprehend because our brains naturally imagine a black empty space when we think of it. Because we think, we cannot comprehend NOT thinking, a lack of self or a lack of sensation. There have been experiments in dead-sound rooms with the lights out. There's next to no smell and all you have is the ability to touch the walls for any sensory feedback, and people absolutely hate it when their actions (even basic ones such as movement and speech) have no reaction. This is what I imagine to be as close as we can get to imagining literal-nothing. I know my idea of "hell" would be something like that over a demon burning my skin and yelling about sin forever.
I've also come to understand something from the kids I teach in a post-religious society (at least when religion is dominant). The behaviour is a lot worse. Its not a popular opinion, particularly from a loony-lefty like me, but I see very often from the kids and now in adults how bored they get of freedom. When you give them 2 choices of something to do, brilliant, they pick one and dedicate time to it. If you say "pick any subject you like to write/draw/talk about", they are far more likely to produce worse work, act out, or get distracted. I could just as easily apply this to single adults without kids (well, lets say adults with lots of free time). They can be anything they want, do anything they want if they really put their mind to it right? So how many of the population are astronauts? How many of them are brilliant scientists? Do you think your local trash collectors want to be trash collectors for the rest of their life? Do you think its more likely that they'd "settle" for lack of a better word, climb a ladder to a management position and maybe executive or start their own company where they can be executive? Sure, the world needs people to do these things, maybe some of them have always wanted to do that for life, but go down to a call centre near you and I guarantee more than half of them have seriously contemplated suicide from having a job that consists of being yelled at by someone with problems caused by someone who isn't you. This ties back to religion's impact on society. It gave people a hope that this mundane, awful little world had something more to it, something that made all the BS worth it like a reward at the end for doing so well. The fewer people who have that strict structure giving them purpose, the more apathetic and miserable day-to-day life appears. Medical depression numbers are at an all time high, something in the region of 30% of people in the UK diagnosed, with a suspected number of sufferers being closer to nearly half. Remember that notion in the first paragraph about people hating the idea of no feedback, no result of their actions, a "reward" for them as it were? Apply that to the literal end of peoples' lives and think about whether everything you've ever put effort into resulted in a reward, why would death be any different?
Interestingly BBB while you profess no belief and I self-proclaim that I am a spiritual man our views on death aren’t that different. I would even dare say we have the same belief of what the dead experience. Many people often envision life in a Hereafter—heaven, hell, purgatory, or even some kind of limbo. Others believe in rebirth as a different life-form (these ones shy away from eating animals). On the other hand, those like yourself who reject religious concepts often believe that death is simply the end of a person’s existence or as you put it “worm food”.
I base my beliefs on what is in the bible, not what is spoon fed to me by others around me but by what is actually in the scriptures. I hope you don’t mind if I quote to share my view. Ecclesiastes 9:10 states that “there is no work nor planning nor knowledge nor wisdom in the Grave, where you are going.” The Bible also explains what happens to both humans and animals at death. Ecclesiastes 3:20 says: “All are going to the same place. They all come from the dust, and they all are returning to the dust.” Psalms 146:4 says “His spirit goes out, he returns to the ground; on that very day his thoughts perish.”
The idea of an immortal soul isn’t actually biblical. This was an idea in Greek philosophy by those like Socrates and Plato that was adopted by the early church at some point. “The soul that sinneth, it shall die.” Ezekiel 18:4 KJV. There isn’t a division of what happens to the soul and body, they both die.
When asked about people suffering in Hell I like to share Ecclesiastes 9:5, 6: “The living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing at all . . . Also, their love and their hate and their jealousy have already perished, and they no longer have any share in what is done under the sun.”. How can someone suffer when they know nothing?
So the first part of my faith is that the dead feel nothing nor think or know. I appreciate that when life ends, that’s it. No more suffering. This thought brings me comfort to know it’s the end of a person’s pain.
The second part of my faith is where we diverge. It is based on the hope of the resurrection. After resting in death, the dead will be resurrected, or brought back to life, on earth by God’s Son. John 5:26, 28, 29 says “Do not be amazed at this, for the hour is coming in which all those in the memorial tombs will hear his voice and come out.”
I find it interesting that we are in agreement on what happens in the present and moment of death. As far as reward vs motivation, this might be a cultural issue or laziness? I know I have to be pushed at times to move forward in my career but is it my faith or just my personality that holds me back? Maybe you see those students as less self reliant and that is a possibility. I believe willingness to do more comes from how a person is raised and the personality they have as a person. Nature vs nurture.
Thank you for sharing.