FDoS mafia is much more similar in terms of gameplay to traditional mafia than EM is.

Not to start a debate or anything in here, I'll leave the decisions to you or numbers, but I think a game without a typical town/mafia dichotomy is probably enough of an outlier, and your game is all personal objectives.

I could go either way. But then again I don't do anything here but maintain the queue. The games are similar enough that if the runners want to have them on the queue I'm not going to say anything about it. But if the runners want to petition for them to not have to run on the queue then I'd just direct them to talk to one of the Gobo in charge of the gaming section since that is ultimately their call on if it constitutes a mafia game or if it's different enough to run separately (like resistance).

And that really goes for any game (I told true the same thing about his battle royal game - at least I'm pretty sure it was true that asked if his game was close enough to dethy to be able to by pass the queue). If you have a game idea that you don't feel is really a mafia game, just ask a gobo to check it over and see if you get approval to jump the queue. I'm inclined to direct you to Scar since I don't really know mafia history of the other gobo though.

Garren_Windspear and NeoSilk are both gobos who play mafia, IIRC.

I was referring to those whose actual area this is. Which looking at the mods for these sections (I'll admit I haven't done for some time; not since kiki and Sapper were around) it looks like its mostly just Scar now. Mastergear (that's garren's work uniform iirc) is in the general section as well. Obviously you wouldn't want to step around them to talk to any old Gobo since this is their area first and foremost.

I want to do a game where everyone has to speak in backwards italian.

sometimes when people have posting restrictions they get modkilled for breaking them

Or completely go with it and win...

Mafia and town lost off site to a serial killer cat who had to post like a cat, was full-bulletproof, and stole an extra gun...

Since we're currently having trouble filling games I'm going to up the Dethy jump to as many as 9 players, assuming you can gather that many around. If we see an over saturation of mini sign ups going up I'll start a secondary queue for them. In the mean time encourage your friends and family to play Isolated Hotel and give them another reason to distrust you!

I'll step down, since the game I had in mind doesn't really work with 9 players, sorry.

I'm gonna change MS Paint Mafia 2 to Mahjong Mafia.

If another month passes without anyone starting a game, I might see if I can bypass the list if I can get 12 people to confirm intent to play in my game.

I will gladly second this. If you get 12 people willing to play, let them play at this point.

If you can get the player base then go for it. Mafia is so dead here that I doubt we even need a queue anymore since the full time player base here can't even fill a game.

Don't worry people will sign up in droves for "Intentionally Trash Game," will def. be a smash hit

MGia idea ok so ten players everyone is a color duo of magic like ravniva holy crap everyone loves that stupid plane woo Boris titss nuts and like nephelim are great I mean some of them but the magic is like who is Boris probably the cops you know ok pariah long wins probably somehow unless Lexi shows up or muppets pretty cool stuff

pariah long

that's a good nickname

Got a (probably terrible) idea for a mafia game that shouldn't be bastard. Signing up in the queue.

If I don't scrap it it is inspired by mtg drafts and the battlestar galactica boardgame.

Ok, my external reviewer spotted no inherent flaw in the set up at a first glance, so I want to confirm my registration for "pick" your role mafia 2:twice the choices, 1.5 times the options, 1.05 times the fun.

There is no queue, only zuul. Anybody that's got a game wants to run a game think they can fill a game just go for it.

Signing up isolated hotel mafia.

I don't care there is no queue