Quote:
honestly lockhammer the list looks really schizo with all of those one-ofs I think this archetype runs better if you were to cut out the black all to gether and run selesnya (like maybe this one here ;p viewtopic.php?f=52&t=10297&start=180#p393894 )
Well, I am just speaking for myself but I love the black control cards. I don't know if I could renounce Languish and the great Ob Nixilis.
Quote:
Might go that route. Was using her as another means to gain Planeswalkers from graveyard.
Can't quite go with that - Shepherd either comes in turn seven or later which means in turn seven, you have to play your land before casting her so you can use her ability in turn 8 if you happen to draw a land which is a lucky shot at this phase of the game. Getting Planeswalkers back is a good idea, especially because Ob Nixilis is likely to have already died when he had to kill off a creature. But you can cast him again only the turn after having cast sheperd. With a Gaea's revenge, you get plain 16 damage in those two turns which will probably decide the game or at least hold off the opponent until Ulamog comes.
I am not too happy with felidar cub either. It can destroy a turn two bloodlust on some weenie but for that, you have to have it on your starting hand. in the later game, it is just a worse Edict. Maybe play another actual edict or a reclamation sage which is only one mana more and can kill off any Chief of Foundry of all the players who haven't heard yet that Thopter aren't really cool anymore (and probably have never been).
And maybe Retreat to Kazandu instead of either one Moss or Natural Connection? Both cards are crucial, yet I am still worried about people playing mono red or red white who beat you down to 6 or 7 life and then finish you off with damage spells. I somehow want to re-gain life against those decks...
Those are my thoughts so far, I apologize for bad English, since I am from Germany.