I feel more comfortable with my vote on Pariah all the time.

I'm not saying you absolutely had to assume that, but I don't think this is a very meaningful line of thought anymore.

---

@PP: You'd like that, wouldn't you?

Might be a fun variant for chat mafia or something. No one is allowed to talk, only vote.

Rubik, discussing what you meant/how I perceive it is very important. If we can figure out how to effectively communicate, mafia will become a cakewalk for town for all but the most skilled liars.

If mafia also figures out what you think is "effective communication", it'll be a cakewalk for them to lie to you.

By effective communication I mean a system where I perceive your meaning as you intend it. Seems like it would place a greater burden on the mafia to lie consistently well or else quickly get called out since everyone understands each other so well.

Discussion is overrated anyway .

I'm curious if JD will actually show my vote, so I'll hold off on a real vote for now.

Other than that, Idk what you guys read, but the wolf role reads to me like this: He can either 1) Kill at night, or 2) Once per game, sire someone, creating the second member of the scum team. I agree that they probably just become like a regular scum team at that point, with 1 nk and can't 'sire' anyone else, so yeah. That really wasn't that confusing.

oh and also OMGUS Lilan.

Wouldn't showing your vote out our hunter? Unless he shows it as stranger.

Vote Count

A Stranger: Freddeh
Freddeh: KoD, Lilan
Zinger: Rubik
PopPa: Niklor
Rubik: Neo

A word of caution. Lynching players unknown to this game may not be the wisest strategy, but I'll allow it.

We did that Niklor at Px2.

Was Mime Mafia but it died because I lost my computer and subsequently internet access.

I see

Unvote; Vote: ProphetKing

If you're going to go with a non player, why not go big and lynch:

Vote: 15377

But, I want to kill the prophetking.

@JD: Was this game a night start, have players had an opportunity to use abilities yet?

I've played games with this setup and usually the only the original can sire people, and only once. (or more with more people)

Day 1: 2/7
Day 2: 2/5
Day 3: 2/3

Day 3 is LyLo. If the hunter shoots LyLo is pushed up to day 2 with a 2/4 split. (or, disastarifically, if the hunter shoots on N2 the game could end right there) For this reason I don't recommend the hunter takes a shot unless we can confirm that the healer has saved someone, and even then its debatable.

thanks niklor

Day 1: 1/8
Day 2: 2/7
Day 3: 2/5
Day 4: 2/3 LyLo

Hunter shot still pushes LyLo back a day, so I don't recommend it.

Day 1: 1/8
Day 2: 2/6
Day 3: 2/4 LyLo

i did the math wrong this is how it is i think

Assuming complete failure by town:

D1:
1/8

N1:
2/7 (2/6 chance of hitting scum from gunner's eye)

D2:
2/6 (LyLo unless doc protects someone)

N2:
2/5 (2/4 chance of hitting scum from gunner's eye)

D3:
2/4 (50% wolves)

---

Assuming a N1 misfire:

D2:
2/5 (LyLo)

N2:
2/4

D3:

2/3 (66% wolves)

The hunter should almost certainly shoot night 2, and shooting night 1 wouldn't be a terrible plan.

2/4 isn't 50% wolves it is one third wolves.