Endless Night, Collector of Antiques, Lich of Lost Treasures, Moss Giant, and Sunchaser Procession shall all be added to the spoiler!

Nominations for more cards are now open, in addition to TP's red cards.

OK, I just went through the second half of every thread and picked out all the cards I liked that didn't win.

Here are the cards TPzombieW nominated last time:


Yay


Yay, with Instant bringer unkeyworded. Also, it should have flash.


Yay


Nay







Please vote Yay, Nay, or Abstain on each of these cards. All cards with more Yays than Nays will be added to the set.

And feel free to nominate any other cards you liked that I missed!

Nothing here is mine, how sad.

Dang Parad, there's a reason I only ever did one colour at a time. Mostly it was procrastination but I'm sure there's a lesson in there anywhere.
Anyhoo, now evebody can copy/paste my list to save some time.

Manaruption - Yay
Sparkcatcher - Could be an elemental instead of faerie, also needs haste. Yay if those conditions are met.
Metalbound Monster - Yay
Minitog - Nay


Secluding Missionary - Yay. Rename it Illpyre Inquisitor or something though.
Written into History - Yay
Simple Repairs - Yay. Needs to be "up to one target creature" though. Kind of worried it will be too swingy with mastery, but it won't hit three targets often.
Solar Revoker - Yay
Inborn Skills - Yay Worried that +2/+2 is too much with the doublestrike though. I mean, you're already essentially getting +2/+1.


Starstill - Abstain
Crystallize - Yay. I think the engrave golems should all be crystal, so this fits nicely.
Humata Sphinx - Yay
Out Cold - Yay Blue could use some tempo I think.
Relic Watcher - Nay
Sundrinker - Yay Awesome
Horizon Hawk - Nay
Frostwing Drake - Nay Cute but how much will it actually do?
Lair-Snapper - Nay. Just doesn't come together somehow.


Path to Power - Nay
Gravepyre - Abstain
Insatiable Abberation - Abstain
Stealer of Strength - Yay Looks like the sort of thing I would- er, it looks fun.


Terracotta Brute - Nay
Worldscorcher - Abstain
Sunfury Spirit - Yay Dat flava! Should be an elemental though.


Duskdriver Baloth - Nay
Earthly Strength - Abstain
Viashino Soulgatherer - Abstain Is this too good?
Natural Rebirth - Yay
Oasis Dryads - Yay
Diamondscale Wurm - Nay


Frostmite - Yay Might need new flavour
Persistence of Mechanation - Yay Needs a less sorceryish name and should cost though.
Frozen Hammer - Nay

That flavor is so bad though >_<

Nominate this thing:

Thanks for the nomination, Lily!


Forgotten Dream –
Creature - Incarnation Illusion (U)
Whenever Forgotten Dream becomes the target of a spell or ability, sacrifice it.
Instant and sorcery spells you cast cost less to cast.
When the artists of Illpyre died in the heat, they left behind the manifestations of their creative ambition. Now, as fleeting as the imaginations they once inhabited, they wander through the eternal desert storm, waiting to inspire whomever might come their way.
2/1

Secluding Missionary - Yay
Written into History - Yay
Simple Repairs - Yay
Solar Revoker - Yay
Inborn Skills - Yay


Starstill - Abstain
Crystallize - Yay
Humata Sphinx - Yay
Out Cold - Yay
Relic Watcher - Abstain
Sundrinker - Yay
Horizon Hawk - Nay
Frostwing Drake - Abstain
Lair-Snapper - Nay


Path to Power - Nay
Gravepyre - Abstain
Insatiable Abberation - Abstain
Stealer of Strength - Yay


Terracotta Brute - Nay
Worldscorcher - Yay
Sunfury Spirit - Yay


Duskdriver Baloth - Nay
Earthly Strength - Abstain
Viashino Soulgatherer - Nay
Natural Rebirth - Yay
Oasis Dryads - Yay
Diamondscale Wurm - Abstain


Frostmite - Nay
Persistence of Mechanation - Yay
Frozen Hammer - Abstain

Not that I'm really attached to the card either way, but for my honor's sake I'd like to disclaim that Duskriver Baloth didn't have affinity as written.

Yea to Secluding Missionary and Sundrinker. Nay to the rest.

Secluding Missionary - 3/0
Written into History - 2/1
Simple Repairs - 2/1
Solar Revoker - 2/1
Inborn Skills - 2/1

Starstill - 0/1
Crystallize - 2/1
Humata Sphinx - 2/1
Out Cold - 2/1
Relic Watcher - 0/2
Sundrinker - 3/0
Horizon Hawk - 0/3
Frostwing Drake - 0/2
Lair-Snapper - 0/3

Path to Power - 0/3
Gravepyre - 0/1
Insatiable Abberation - 0/1
Stealer of Strength - 2/1

Terracotta Brute - 0/3
Worldscorcher - 1/1
Sunfury Spirit - 2/1

Duskdriver Baloth - 0/3
Earthly Strength - 0/1
Viashino Soulgatherer - 0/2
Natural Rebirth - 2/1
Oasis Dryads - 2/1
Diamondscale Wurm - 0/2

Frostmite - 1/2
Persistence of Mechanation - 2/1
Frozen Hammer - 0/2

Secluding Missionary (renamed Illpyre Inquisitor), Written into History, Simple Repairs, Solar Revoker, Inborn Skills (with the +2/+2 changed to +1/+1, as TP and I both think is prudent);
Crystallize, Humata Sphinx, Out Cold, Sundrinker;
Stealer of Strength;
Sunfury Spirit;
Natural Rebirth, Oasis Dryands;
and Persistence of Mechanation (renamed Composite Construct)...

Shall all be added to the spoiler!

Also, I'm going to add Forgotten Dream and Control Bug, too, since nobody voted against them.

That's got to take us pretty close to a small set's worth of cards.

Yeah, by my count this as well as the Reprints thread leaves us at 195 cards. 50 more to go! Time for Hole Filling.

We should probably update the "The Set So Far" thread as well as any "Set Map" spoiler blocks, and probably the visual spoiler at some point, so that we can get an idea of what we have and what we need.

Yeah, I'm doing that right now. Give me a couple hours and I should be done.