So someone posted an idea for this and a few others showed interest in it so here is a randomness draft.

The packs will be made entirely out of random cards. So there could be more then 1 rare per pack easily and sometimes there might be no rare. I'm allowing any card from magic history including un cards mainly because i think it could be fun.

The only rule I have is every pack needs to have at least 2 cards of each color in it.\

Pack 1:

Darksteel Pendant
Lure
Duskworker
Quillspike
Arnjlot's Ascent
Valeron Outlander
Eternal Dragon
Lash of the Whip
Peregrine Drake
Underground Sea
Metathran Elite
Rolling Terrain
Fireball
Oppression
Neurok Invisimancer

Take the dragon.

Dragon indeed.

The dragon looks horrible. For 9 mana you get two plains? And then you can play a 7 drop on turn 9 or so?

Take fireball. It's awesome.

Dragon but it's close.

Greven -- are these cards chosen with any consideration of rarity at all? Like there could be 10 "copies" of each common and 3 of each uncommon in your "pool" (or actually you'd have to multiply by 8 for mythics). Or is it just 1:1:1:1?

Early game it gives you land. Late game it's a recurrable, flying beater. Seems good to me.

I'd play it in sealed, but right now it's just a 2-mana plains-fetcher that might turn into a game-ending-7-drop in the event we're playing against a Walls deck. I mean, really, if you fetch one plains with it, then recur it, then cast it, it's a 14-mana creature that made you give up a couple of turns. That's hysterically bad to me, particularly when random formats tend to have old school removal like... fireball. You wanna spend 14 mana and 3 turns on one card? Thanks for the free timewalks!

Coincidentally, blowing up someone's face with a fireball in the late game is just as effective.

Well, knowing what kind of format it is generally helps with decisions like these. I'm inclined to go with Fireball as it seems like the safer pick.

I like Fireball here. It's a bomb uncommon, while Eternal Dragon feels more like an okay rare.

My reason for preferring dragon is that I assume that random cards will be slow enough for it to matter.

Neurok Invisimancer

If we are going totally random, we all know which color is the strongest. Plus, a three-mana two-power unblockable guy can probably win the game by itself in this format, maybe deal more damage in a game than the Fireball.

Dragon. Random cards are going to want that fixing, and the high cost shouldn't be an issue in the end.

Dragon thins our deck and fixes our colors, then acts as a mana sink if we topdeck poorly; it's the pick.

I actually like Neurok Invisimancer also. Its extremely relevant early, and late game turns a big bomb into a heat-seeking missile.

I also vote for Eternal Dragon.

Eternal Dragon

~SE++

Think of it as a lategame wincon that can also landcycle early. Then add in the fact that it can be your lategame wincon even after you landcycle it early, and you have a pretty strong card.

Pack 1:

Eternal Dragon

Next...

Warthog
Clockwork Avian
Viashivan Dragon
Esper Charm
Lightning Helix
Miren, the Moaning Well
Benalish Knight
Hurloon Minotaur
Nether Shadow
Browbeat
Forbidden Ritual
Jungle Weaver
Sand Squid
Iron Myr

Helix if we want to commit early. If we do not, I like the Knight.

I'll go helix