Let's start the voting!












I vote for Knifethrower.

It seems like everyone else had the same trouble I did, because a lot of these don't feel common, don't feel like enchantments, or just don't justify black caring about enchantments.

thatmarkguy's card edges out Effigy's for me.

I must admit that I don't get this whole "Enchantment feel". What do enchantments feel like? As long as the flavor somehow justifies it, I must admit I don't really care that much.
With that said, Shazzeh Parad for being the closest to what I want black enchantment creatures to now be.

thatmarkguy

Confused.

I didn't submit a card this round but I appreciate your support all the same.

Flavor is probably most of the "enchantment feel" but we could also have a mechanic like bestow that justifies it. We don't really have anything like yet but I still think something can actively feel not like an enchantment. Like, I like Knifethrower's card as a card, but it feels like a weird choice for this round because what kind of enchantment has an ETB drawback and no other abilities? I guess it's that I think enchantment creatures should have some kind of effect on the battlefield that has nothing to do with them being a creature.

I'm not sure if it's an inconvential way of saying that I dislike all the entries, or if my bias is showing.

That was supposed to be Parad.

I'll go with Confused. Two months ago I wouldn't have thought this is in-pie for Black until Feast of Dreams demonstrated that it is.

Final Tally:

thatmarkguy: 2
Confused: 2
Parad: 1.5
Knifethrower: 1

thatmarkguy wins the tie because he voted for Confused, but Confused didn't vote. Shamebearer has been added to the spoiler!

Please pick a rarity and write a criterion for the next round.

We haven't even touched rares or mythic yet in black.

Black rare creature. Something you'll want to attack with (not a small utility creature like Royal Assassin / Dark Confidant / Will o the Wisp / Wall of whatever).

Memoria Vampiris –
Creature – Vampire Wizard (R)
Flying, hexproof
Mastery—When Memoria Vampiris enters the battlefield, if you control an artifact, a creature, an enchantment, and a land, gain control of target creature.
It wipes your memory of everything but its eternal whisper.
4/4

Spectral Loner
Creature—Spirit (R)
Haste
You may cast ~ from your graveyard.
When a player controls another creature, sacrifice ~.
When the world was made inhospitable to life, darker things prospered.
3/1

Spirit of Cold Nights -
Creature - Spirit
Whenever ~ deals damage to an opponent, it deals that much damage to each tapped creature he or she controls.
Whenever ~ deals damage to a tapped creature, draw a card.
4/6

Demon of Ancient Misery
Creature-demon (R)
Flying, trample
Whenever [cardname] deals damage to an opponent, put a Relic artifact token onto the battlefield. (Relics have no abilities)
At the beginning of your upkeep, sacrifice an artifact or creature.
He remembers the pain of changing seasons, and he plans to inflict it again.
5/5

Reprint Salvage Titan

Continuing on my quest to bankrupt Illpyre's tourism industry:

Treacherous Caravaneer
Creature - Human Wizard (R)
When Treacherous Caravaneer enters the battlefield, put three 2/2 black Zombie creature tokens onto the battlefield, then sacrifice three creatures.
Although their zombies' food can be morally difficult to procure at times, necromancers enjoy impunity in the anarchy of the desert.
4/3

Frostwind Lich
Creature - Zombie Wizard
Deathtouch
At the end of each turn, if 3 or more creatures died this turn and ~ is in your graveyard, return it to the battlefield.
3/1

Undead Collector
Creature - Zombie Wizard
When ~ enters the battlefield, you may exile up to one each of creature, artifact, enchantment, land and insstant or sorcery cards from target opponent's graveyard.
Whenever a creature you control deals combat damage to a player, you may cast one of the exiled cards without paying its mana cost.
3/4
He covets many things in this world, foremost being the world itself.

Lifesapper --
Creature - Plant (R)

Lifelink
At the beginning of your end step, if Lifesapper is untapped, you lose 5 life.

5 / 2

Soul Furnace
Enchantment Creature - Spirit
Intimidate
Surge — , Exile two creature cards from your graveyard. (You may cast ~ for its surge cost. If you do, it enters the battlefield with haste. Sacrifice it at the beginning of your next end step.)
You may cast ~ for its surge cost from your graveyard.
3/2