Lament for the Past -
Instant
Choose one - Return target creature card from your graveyard to its owner's hand; Or, exile target creature card from any graveyard and put a 2/2 black Zombie creature onto the battlefield.

Let's start the voting!






















I vote for Shazzeh.

Parad.

if only cato's card wasn't so confusing...

Black cantripping makes sense if we want casting spells to matter,but I really like fakeartist's card, I vote for him.

Shazzeh.

There are very few of these that makes me think "Yes, this will go well in my spells deck", so I guess I'll go with the slightly radical Parad. I sort of pity black's color pie, so it's not too bad really.

Fakeartist's Parish the Notion

Confused

fakeartist - INSTANT SPEED DISCARD?!? If there is a card type pie, this breaks it.

Parad

I vote Fakeartist

Current Tally:

ParadOxymoron: 3
Fakeartist: 3
Shazzeh: 2
Confused: 1

And we have a tie! Knifethrower, please vote for ParadOxymoron, Fakeartist, or Shazzeh to break the tie.

Isn't Shazzeh at two? But Shazzeh does get my vote if possible. Otherwise, FakeArtist. Btw, Mindlash Sliver and Necrogen Spellbomb are both instant speed discard.

OK, Shazzeh's at 3 now. We still have a tie, though.

I think we might need a clarification on the voting procedure (probably best for the general discussion thread). I'll copypaste this there.

I would expect (but today's procedure has contradicted):
When the gate closes on voting, 'normal' voting is finished. If there is a leader, it wins. If there is a tie for leader and one of the tied was voted-for by the criteria-maker, that one wins. If there is a tie for the leader and the criterion-maker either didn't vote at all or didn't vote for one of the ties, the criterion-maker chooses from among the tied which one wins.

I don't think other votes after the close-of-voting should count. And if the criterion maker didn't vote before close-of-voting, then that criterion maker has missed the opportunity to make a normal vote, and is now just breaking the tie from among the actual leaders (and not ones that would become leaders with the addition of the criterionmaker's vote).

That's just me though.

I vote Fakeartist again

KFM, I'm trying not to snap at you, but you most certainly can't vote twice. And PLEASE a) put your renders in spoilers and b) keep them to the The Set So Far thread.

If I may change my vote, I'd vote for Shazzeh

See this post for how we're going to deal with ties in the future and prevent this haphazardry going forward.

And Shazzeh takes it! Mindshivers has been added to the spoiler.

Please pick a rarity and write a criterion for the next round.

Lol, ok, was worth the try... really like that card.... will keep voting for it...

Oh! Wow.

Make a black common that cares about a specific card type other than instants.