Mmmm. IDK if that'll work, really.
The place seems pretty unambiguous between frozen and charred.

ParadOxymoron for this one, even if his card is really weak.
Would possibly slap on the ability to block more creatures. Would be nice if there was some way to make the toughness matter outside or removal and trample.

I like parad's

I'd like Parad's if it had Flash. Shazzeh gets my vote.

Current Tally

Parad – 2
Lily – 1
altimis – 1
Shazzeh - 1

Voting ends in five hours.

At the expense of simplicity, add another vote for Lily.

Even though my card is winning tied for the lead, it's quite flawed. It needs either flash, the ability to block any number of creatures, or to be a common. If it wins, does anyone have a problem if I edit it to be one of these three things? I'm leaning towards the ability to block any number of creatures, because that would make it on a par with a blue Fog.

The reason I'm asking is because I'm nervous to set a precedent for people editing their cards after they've been voted for—but I really don't think that should be much of a problem. For example, I encourage Mown to write flavor text for Frostblight Scavenger.

With Shazzeh's vote and the new tiebreak procedure, you're not winning anymore.

I don't like the precedent of a functional change after voting opens. Flavor text, reminder text, and maybe even cardname I could see, but not a functional change.

(I also think Flash is way more-blue than multiblock - I'd expect that multiblock on a White card).

Word, ok. Just making sure. As long as even one person has a problem with it, I won't do it.

I actually thought about adding flash but decided that would make it too powerful. Psh.

I think we'll eventually need yet another thread to discuss cards already in the set.

Speaking of how many threads there are, I'm sending a PM to GobO_Slobad to ask if we can have a Starstill subforum. This is clogging up the boards.

Since we decided that the person the criterion setter voted for wins the tie, and Mown voted for me, I take this one. Wall of Clouds has been added to the spoiler.

Next round:

Blue Mythic. Create a card depicting the ancient event that caused the plane to stop moving.

Sad.

Unending Night
Legendary Enchantment (M)
When Unending Night enters the battlefield, put a frost counter on each permanent and tap those permanents.
If one or more permanents with frost counters on them a player controls would become untapped, instead that player removes a frost counter from one of those permanents.
When Unending Night leaves the battlefield, remove all frost counters from all permanents.

I'm sorry, Lily. Does the fact that you inspired my criterion make up for it?

Can I suggest the name Frostwyndigo for a future card
Nevermind, new submission...

Glacinorak, the Frozen Heart --
Legendary Creature - Dragon (MR)

Flying
When Glacinorak, the Frozen Heart enters the battlefield, tap all other permanents. Those permanents can't untap until your next turn.

"The seasons distrubed me; for once my brother agreed with me.
5 / 7

So, basically... Final Fortune for 6? I don't get it.

Just upheaval afterward.

Starstill
Sorcery

Tap each permanent. They can't untap (this effect lasts indefinitely).

It's a bit easier and omore interesting to work around this than it is for final fortune.
Plus if you gained control of your opponents creatures or anything, during that turn, they would remain tapped for the remainder of the game.

I have another thought for a potential mythic rare. Are we only allowed to post one card at a time?