No Goblins Allowed
http://862838.jrbdt8wd.asia/

Suggested Changes
http://862838.jrbdt8wd.asia/viewtopic.php?f=47&t=6554
Page 1 of 2

Author:  ParadOxymoron [ Sat Oct 11, 2014 2:04 am ]
Post subject:  Suggested Changes

In this thread, we're going to suggest changes for Starstill based on the experiences we've had in playtesting. Which changes we go forward with and which we don't will be determined by general consensus in this thread, rather than official voting.

It seems like red doesn't have a hard removal spell at common like Turn to Slag, which would go a long way toward solving the problem. I recommend putting it in over Hellish Sandstorm.

Hello World also commented that there was too much fixing in a non-multicolor set. Grovecaller Ouphe, Viashino Suncaller, Abundant Growth, and Loamblood Druid are all rainbow fixers. We should think about restricting some of these to Forests or green mana only.

Lilan wrote:
Also, am I reading lifeblood of maraka right? I haven't seen anyone talking about it but does it deal 17 damage if you drop it on the opponent turn 3 and they can't answer it right away?

I think gift of maraka is way too strong in limited to be common. It makes blocking a complete nightmare.

TPmanW wrote:
I noticed we lack a shock variant (shock with engrave, done) or an overrun effect. Combat tricks in general are also lacking.

Also, we need to officially decide what to do about Bahraz. That's what most of the discussion in the Block Constructed thread has been focused on, but we haven't come to a consensus yet.

Author:  chinkeeyong [ Sat Oct 11, 2014 3:35 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

I've already suggested some numbers tweaks:
Bahraz the Tyrant

Planeswalker - Bahraz (M)


Each opponent loses 2 life. You gain life equal to the life lost this way.
Destroy all creatures with converted mana cost less than the number of loyalty counters on Bahraz the Tyrant.
As long as there are ten or more loyalty counters on Bahraz, he's a 20/20 God creature with protection from everything in addition to his other types.

Author:  Kithkin_FieldMarshal [ Sat Oct 11, 2014 4:09 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Quote:
Hello World also commented that there was too much fixing in a non-multicolor set. Grovecaller Ouphe, Viashino Suncaller, Abundant Growth, and Loamblood Druid are all rainbow fixers. We should think about restricting some of these to Forests or green mana only.


The only way green can survive at the moment is to splash other colors. Im playing GRU.... and I can only agro play and combo.... I cant wait to build up my big creatures coz of all the creature hate.

Author:  Kithkin_FieldMarshal [ Mon Oct 13, 2014 12:44 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

There is a slight issue with Restoration Spirit, the way it is worded at the moment, you can return a Land from the graveyard. Newer players might think that you can play one land from your hand and another with Restoration Spirit. There are two ways t fix this.... make Restoration Spirit only return non land permanent or have a rule text saying "One Land can still only be played a turn."

Author:  Kithkin_FieldMarshal [ Mon Oct 13, 2014 2:10 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Hey Chinkeeyong

Here is an explanation on how to add card images to Cockatrice

http://www.gatheringmagic.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=25&t=17014

Author:  chinkeeyong [ Mon Oct 13, 2014 4:54 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

I know how to add card images to Cockatrice, but I intend to eventually add Starstill to NGA Constructed, which has thousands of cards without images. It would be incongruous to have some cards in the plugin with images and others without.

Author:  Dudibus [ Tue Oct 14, 2014 10:44 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

I read that post and I didn't find it really told me how to add images. It mentions a tag you can use in the xml, but not what that tag was. <image>?

Author:  TPmanW [ Tue Oct 14, 2014 1:44 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Don't forget these:
TPmanW wrote:
Suggestions:

We have 11 cards that cost . Yeah...
It's hard to get Spark Of Imagination to do anything. There are only only two red 1 cmc instants for it to cast. Even going into other colours, almost everything is situational. I say raise the cost to and let it cast 1 and 2 drops.
We should pick one or two creatures to pump up in order to balance Bahraz. Look for what strategies need it the most or what cards are coolest.
Reification Of Elori could use a boost. I recommend dropping the cost and stats to 5/5 and .
Gleam Collector's haste doesn't do much. You'll probably want to sit on a Gleam Collector before attacking anyways. I recommend swapping haste out for intimidate.
Frostwynd Colossus is cool enough that I want to push it a bit. Could we find a way to let multiple copies of it untap without interfering with each other? Perhaps it only keeps your lands or your other creatures from untapping?
Knifetail Ambush and Raid the Ruins are uncomfortably similar.
I'd keep an eye on Remove From Reality. That's a pretty sweet white tempo play. Might want to make it a sorcery.

Author:  chinkeeyong [ Tue Oct 14, 2014 8:45 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Could you format the changes in a more concrete changelist form?

Also, note that Spark of Imagination has already been errataed to , 2 drops.

Author:  Hello World [ Wed Oct 15, 2014 12:17 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

I wrote something about white in the sealed/draft thread, I'll try to do the other colors later today.
I'm not a fan of what some charms do at common since they add a lot of board complexity, maybe we can make them a cycle of enchantments with oblation?

Author:  TPmanW [ Thu Oct 16, 2014 12:34 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Problems and proposed solutions:

Bahraz's Steed and Frsotblight Shadowwalker compete for space. Identical stats, similar protection abilities, similar costs.
-Cut one.

We have 11 cards that cost .
-Cut/enlarge three or so of them.

Spark Of Imagination can hardly cast anything.
-I recommend letting it hit higher casting cost cards. Possibly recost to compensate.
-Alternatively add a good one drop red instant/sorcery.

Lack of large creatures. This is undermining several arrhetypes and letting others get out of control.
-Apply serious steroids to two or three rare creatures.

Reification Of Elori is too weak.
-Make it a six drop as a 5/5.

Gleam Collector's haste is pontless. You'd hardly ever want to attack with it first turn.
-Swapping haste out for intimidate or a lower cost.

Knifetail Ambush and Raid the Ruins are uncomfortably similar.
-Cut one.

Author:  chinkeeyong [ Thu Oct 16, 2014 12:54 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

TPmanW wrote:
Cut one.

Which one?

TPmanW wrote:
-Cut/enlarge three or so of them.

Which three? Enlarge by how much?

You get the gist.

Author:  TPmanW [ Thu Oct 16, 2014 2:08 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Sorry, I was trying to take it step by step. I can make more specific recommendations at a later point when it is less midnight.

Author:  Hello World [ Thu Oct 16, 2014 6:15 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Weird I trought there was a ramp deck focusing on reification and will of makara to outlast the opponent with gigantic mana dorks.
You guys are gettiing kinda close to miserable to play against in limited with those two cards.

Author:  Hello World [ Fri Oct 17, 2014 7:27 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

Looking at starstill com

Consortium engineer and sneaky gadgerer are both 2/1 for :1::u: that are conditionally unblockable, maybe move one up in cost and stats?

Turn back at common scares me, but whatever.

Blue draws and filters a lot.

Bombs are bomby.

Student of finality screams rare.

What CKY said about hellish snowstorm.

Storm volley can probably lose the red restriction, the second :r: or switch back to be until the end of turn now.
Groveskipper ouphe doesn't feel common.

Snapping land wurm feels common

I don't get crushtread sage,or maybe I do?dun-dun-dun.

Lifeblood of maraka costs really little for what it does.

Druid herloom is really strong for common, viashino warwagon too, may I suggest making it a 3/3 haste? It even makes the drawback more drawbacky.
Blade of ispiration is REALLY generous, has anybody tried it in constructed?
Coldmetal coat is pretty strong too.
Shatterspear insigna doesn't feel rare.
Forgotten library is scary at common, do we really want players to find their bombs this much?
The spires are costed aggressively too.

Author:  TPmanW [ Fri Oct 17, 2014 9:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

I agree with Hello World on all counts, even the bits that aren't suggestions. Except maybe the Sandwurm going common. Kind of indifferent there.

Suggestions:

Cut Frostblight Shadow-walker
Make Student Of Finality a rare.

Cut Raid the Ruins
Let Spark of Imagination cast red instants or sorceries with converted mana cost two or less.
Gleam collector drop haste, add intimidate.

Make Hellish Snowstorm uncommon.

I think Adaptive Yeti was supposed to have trample.
Change Gift of Maraka's bonus from +2/+2 to +1/+1. Change cost to .

Add to the activation cost of Manufactory.
Make Forgotten Library's activation cost instead of .

Viashino WarWagon common -> uncommon
Blade Of Inspiration. Change stat boost from +2/+2 to +2/+0
Druid's Heirloom up cost to
Coldmetal Coat lower cost to and lower bonus to +0/+2.
Instead of lower rarity. Have Shatterpsear Insignia give +1/+0.
Bumpe Archamge's Staff down to uncommon.


We could use hexproof on one of our big green critters but I'm having trouble deciding which. Tyrant Wurm?

Author:  ParadOxymoron [ Mon Oct 20, 2014 11:22 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

TPmanW wrote:
I agree with Hello World on all counts, even the bits that aren't suggestions. Except maybe the Sandwurm going common. Kind of indifferent there.

Suggestions:

Cut Frostblight Shadow-walker
Make Student Of Finality a rare.

Cut Raid the Ruins
Let Spark of Imagination cast red instants or sorceries with converted mana cost two or less.
Gleam collector drop haste, add intimidate.

Make Hellish Snowstorm uncommon.

I think Adaptive Yeti was supposed to have trample.
Change Gift of Maraka's bonus from +2/+2 to +1/+1. Change cost to .

Add to the activation cost of Manufactory.
Make Forgotten Library's activation cost instead of .

Viashino WarWagon common -> uncommon
Blade Of Inspiration. Change stat boost from +2/+2 to +2/+0
Druid's Heirloom up cost to
Coldmetal Coat lower cost to and lower bonus to +0/+2.
Instead of lower rarity. Have Shatterpsear Insignia give +1/+0.
Bumpe Archamge's Staff down to uncommon.


We could use hexproof on one of our big green critters but I'm having trouble deciding which. Tyrant Wurm?

I'm good with all these. Archmage's Staff was actually submitted as an uncommon IIRC, but I bumped it up to rare because I thought it made sense there. So bumping it back down would make sense.

Also, it's been weeks and I've only played one game of Starstill, with Knifethrower. And that was a Limited game. If anyone can play Constructed with me, please shoot me a PM.

Author:  TPmanW [ Mon Oct 20, 2014 9:57 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

I've got decks ready now, so if you ever see me online I'll be willing.

Author:  ParadOxymoron [ Tue Oct 21, 2014 2:09 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

CKY's suggested nerf to Bahraz makes him feel lame. I think if we changed his starting loyalty to 3 that would be enough of a nerf.

Author:  Hello World [ Tue Oct 21, 2014 2:32 am ]
Post subject:  Re: Suggested Changes

My only problem is that the -0 seems oppressive, maybe add a then remove two loyalty counters from brahaz at the end of it.

Page 1 of 2 All times are UTC - 6 hours [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/