OK but if the original wins I really think we should up the rarity to UNC.

Also you missed dudibus's entry.

Since I can't vote for my own I vote for the original, ammended to a shuffle-in rather than bottomdeck perhaps?

If I were making a card, I would just make it shuffle in an artifact and perhaps cost 1 more.

okay i switch my vote to the original

i actually really liked the design

idc what rarity its at

Dangit folks all we really had to do was change "cmc of 0" -> "artifact or land" and the rarity issue would've cleared up.
I kind of hate the original and all the replacements. No vote.

Yeah, OK. No vote.

Let's just change "cmc 0" to "artifact or land"

Anybody have a problem with that?

I don't really see why, but it's fine.

i'm fine either way

I'll settle for that.

I think it should shuffle, since part of the starting disagreement was that bottomdecking didn't feel red. Shuffle-in does feel red, and it's little different.

I think it's less flavorful, and unnecessary shuffles should probably be avoided since they're annoying in real life.

bottomdecking is red enough and is pretty much the point of the card. I'd rather it just destroy before shuffle-in.

As long as it doesn't trigger engrave tokens (exile, shuffle, bottom) and doesn't mention cmc I can live with it.

Ok I think that change should go ahead and be made then. Cmc 0 -> artifact or land.

Sounds good.