It's that magical time of year again where we come together to logic and puzzle and piece together who is naughty and who is nice. This is Dethy.

If you're unfamiliar with Dethy, this game will be for at least five players. In the standard five variant four players are cop roles of varying sanity and one player will be the scum Krampus. The cops will represent each of the four sanities (Sane, Insane, Naive, and Paranoid) but will be unaware of which one they are.

This will be a five player variant. Given experienced players know a dethy strategy like a veteran tic tac toe player, Krampus has been given an ace up his sleeve like years past. Keep that in mind.

The game will start with Night 0, in which all abilities but the mafia kill will be usable. Progressing into day players will reveal their results and attempt to lynch the Krampus. Wash, Rinse, Repeat.

Player List:
1. KoD
2. Neo
3. Aaarrrgh
4. Dusky
5. Lilan

It is now Night 0. Send in any roles or questions as method of confirmation. You have 48 hours.

Results are out. It's now Day 1. I'll set a deadline later, depending on how activity goes.

I'm told that you've been a good boy this year Arrgh.

KoD has not only been naughty, but very naughty. As expected.

I know where this holiday is going for you.

Neo, you seem to have gotten your wires crossed. KoD is on the nice list.

I investigated myself and got naughty

Ooh, power play from Lilan.

Always power plays from that one. The interesting thing here, though, is that Lilan's move leaves us lacking with any expansion upon her own alignment wrt to her result.

*Squints eyes.*

Ignore me for right now.

any cop result in a vacuum does nothing in this setup

in retrospect i probably should have targeted KoD since i might guess having more targets on one person makes analysis easier later, especially if flips exist in this game.

My mind was elsewhere when I saw that you targeted yourself. Mostly from the last time.

I was informed that Aaargh is on the naughty list.

So we have three naughty results: Dusky (target: Arrgh), Neo (target: KoD), and Lilan (target: herself).

And two nice results: KoD (target: Arrgh), and Arrgh (target: KoD)

Right off the bat either Dusky, Neo, or Lilan is Krampus.

It is now a matter of figuring out which two of those three are the paranoid and insane Kris Kringle.

Whichever of the three is Krampus will have a hard time finding out who the paranoid and insane Santas are. From what I can see, it would be best to focus results on either of those three (especially for the naive and insane Santas).

Thoughts?

KoD, we cannot exclude anyone from being Krampus just yet. For instance, you could be Krampus if Neo is sane.

Yeah, that’s an impossible leap to take.
The real question, is are we allowed to no lynch? If so, I suggest we move on to N1.

@Arrgh:

That is one, less likely, possibility, sure.

@Neo:

Not impossible. It is a logical leap to make. Either way, I'm 100% confident one of you is Krampus.

Deviating from my norm, if a unanimous consensus is reached day will immediately end in no Lynch. Otherwise day will end at deadlines with a lynch held on the player with the most votes.

I support no lynching today so we can sonic into the next day.