Altimis rolls:


s_e rolls:


Sending out hands to keep/mull now. After both have confirmed to keep/mull, you can start.

I keep.
Oh, and I think I'll draw first too

GO SQUINTY!

Sorry, been out all day, I'll keep.

Do I get to call if I go first since I got the higher roll?

~SE++

@S_e: That is correct.
@Alt: Hands only first. You wouldn't want that first draw to influence your mulligan decision, would you?

@Both:
Here's a turn template as I used back in the day

I was joking, because squinty got a higher roll than me.
Also, for you squinty_eyes (I know the phasing rules almost backwards):
http://wizards.custhelp.com/app/answers ... /a_id/629/

The easiest way to describe it:
The creature is (essentially) entering and leaving the battlefield without triggering any ETB or LTB abilities (it does trigger phasing abilities). When it is phased out, the permanent ceases to exist, and effects do not count it as being on the battlefield.

The most important thing:
*Phasing is attached to the untap step, before everything untaps (Phasing, Untap, Upkeep, Draw, Play etc.). That means, if a player doesn't get an untap step, phasing doesn't happen. (Things with phasing don't phase out, phased out things don't phase in.)

Which way would you prefer me to represent phased out permanents?
(in order of my preference)
This is normal to compare to ==>Taniwha, Taniwha, Taniwha**, Taniwha(Phased)

Testing for some of the format stuff...

Tapped icon can be done with or you could write out tapped

Untap
Upkeep
Draw

Play Hallowed Fountain (tapped, no life loss)

Pass Turn

-----------------------------

Untapped: [None]

Tapped: Hallowed Fountain

Command Zone: Zur the Enchanter

-----------------------------

Cards in Hand: 7
Life: 40
Commander Damage: 0

~SE++

Seriously, Commander text duel??? This is gonna take a long time to finish.

Not Taniwha versus Zur *sigh* lol
And takes an extra three key presses compared to T

My turn:

U.U.D.

I play an Island. Untapped, no life loss
You may go.

--xx--

Commandzone: Taniwha

--xx--

Creatures:
Artifacts:
Enchantments:
Lands: (Note: I will write out nonbasic lands' names)

--xx--

Life: 40 (00 Commander)
Hand: 07
Graveyard: 00 (-)
Exile: 00 (-)

Untap
Upkeep
Draw

Play Darkslick Shores untapped.
Cast Angelic Renewal
Pass turn.

-----------------------------

Untapped: Angelic Renewal

Tapped: Hallowed Fountain, Darkslick Shores

Command Zone: Zur the Enchanter

-----------------------------

Cards in Hand: 7
Life: 40
Commander Damage: 0

~SE++

U.U.D.

I play an Island.
You may go.

--xx--

Commandzone: Taniwha

--xx--

Creatures:
Artifacts:
Enchantments:
Lands: ,

--xx--

Life: 40 (00 Commander)
Hand: 07
Graveyard: 00 (-)
Exile: 00 (-)

Untap
Upkeep
Draw

Play Dimir Guildgate (tapped).
Pass turn.

-----------------------------

Untapped: Angelic Renewal, Hallowed Fountain, Darkslick Shores

Tapped: Dimir Guildgate

Command Zone: Zur the Enchanter

-----------------------------

Cards in Hand: 6
Life: 40
Commander Damage: 0
Graveyard: 0
Exile: 0

~SE++

U.U.D.

I play an Island.
I cast Mana Breach.
I say, "Have fun with that"
You may go.

--xx--

Commandzone: Taniwha

--xx--

Creatures:
Artifacts:
Enchantments: Mana Breach.
Lands: , ,

--xx--

Life: 40 (00 Commander)
Hand: 06
Graveyard: 00 (-)
Exile: 00 (-)

Untap
Upkeep
Draw

Play Swamp.
Cast Zur the Enchanter from the Command Zone.
Return Swamp to my hand.
Pass turn.

-----------------------------

Untapped: Angelic Renewal, Zur the Enchanter

Tapped: Dimir Guildgate, Hallowed Fountain, Darkslick Shores

Command Zone: [None]

-----------------------------

Cards in Hand: 7
Life: 40
Commander Damage: 0
Graveyard: 0
Exile: 0

~SE++

U.U.D.

I play an Island.
I cast Teferi's Curse targeting Zur. I return one of the tapped Islands to my hand.
You may go.

--xx--

Commandzone: Taniwha

--xx--

Creatures:
Artifacts:
Enchantments: Mana Breach, Teferi's Curse(Zur the Enchanter)
Lands: , ,

--xx--

Life: 40 (00 Commander)
Hand: 06
Graveyard: 00 (-)
Exile: 00 (-)

(I haven't gotten my draw, but I doubt I'll cast, so one card in my hand is unknown)

Untap - (Zur the Enchanter Phases out)
Upkeep
Draw

Play Sunken Ruins.
Pass turn.

-----------------------------

Untapped: Angelic Renewal, Dimir Guildgate, Hallowed Fountain, Darkslick Shores, Sunken Ruins

Tapped: [None]

Phased Out: Zur the Enchanter (enchanted with Teferi's Curse)

Command Zone: [None]

-----------------------------

Cards in Hand: 7
Life: 40
Commander Damage: 0
Graveyard: 0
Exile: 0

~SE++

I went before I drew last time, because I knew I didn't want you to get Zur lol.
As such I would have two unknown cards if I went now, so I'll wait for Jac and go later today.

Fair enough. And nice move with Teferi's Curse.

~SE++

Thank you.
I am expecting the worst from Zur, so when I saw that in my opening hand I'm like "KEEP. Sweet mother do I keep this."