On a more serious note, Mongoose's fixation on me is either a fundamental misunderstanding of DETHY (I was obviously reporting a result on Neon) or a very poor attempt to frame me as scum.

I am also somewhat suspicious of Zinger claiming to possess a full list of alignments. I doubt that Jay would construct a game that could be so easily broken, as Town's imperfect knowledge is the only thing that makes the game a game. (Though, conversely, scum does often know all alignments.)

The lack of an NLP also concerns me.

I updated Zingers table

The only thing that stands out, is that KoD got a naughty result 3 out of 4 times.
And those who targeted him on N0 died.

Therefore:

Vote: KoD

My second choice would be Zinger because he is lying for whatever reason.

can i be sane with a naughty result on argh?

we don't know what the krampus special is this game right, or if it even exists?

@KoD well that is elementary my dear KoD. You see that would be Skystone and his Scum buddies trying to direct suspicion from themselves, and direct it towards you. The fact that you pointed it out that way gives you Town Pants in my book.

Low effort posting time since I am bad at remembering to check this daily!

From high scum to low scum with bonus cop guess:

Mongoose - Naive - Vote on Skystone seems super sus, no stated reason but the effort of attempting to make a reason exists

Zinger - Insane? - Low effort posting with no NLP, though lots of people pointing it out
Darkstar - Sane - If Zinger is Insane then that implies that Dark is scum, but not 100% on that.

KoD - Maybe Sane? - KoD posting, unsure, could be?
Rag - Paranoid/Insane - Idk

Dusky - Guessing Insane, but sane would be interesting - Idk
Skystone - Paranoid/Insane - Idk, but did like the first post a bit so leaning towards town



KoD with 3 naughties feels too easy, would rather take another day to feel it out if i can, so lets go with

Vote: Mongoose

I can't discount that the maybe lack of knowledge on DETHY (or even reading the rules/thread) led to the vote on Sky, Goose has been active enough to lead me to that not being the case.

Actually, does this count as low effort? idk, this is what you get.

Oh and I guess I'm either Sane or Naive.

Also as a side note what does Fake mean in DETHY? Fake as in there is no cop results for mafia or fake as in they just get all faked results?

Also also I just realized that there weren't even the DETHY rules posted so lul to that, reading the thread part does still apply though.

My candidates for today are Zinger and Mongoose. Given that I am currently tied in voting with the latter, I will opt for that possibility.

I am nurturing skepticism about KoD.

Vote: Mongoose


That said, there's an argument (depending on how many scum we have) to do the standard DETHY thing and

Since the flips don't show role names but I am expiring soon I will tell you this: I am not a cop and don't pick any targets at night. I assume the results I receive are random (but do not know).

Why Zinger, why Mongoose?

Skystone:... and what?

@Dark: Mongoose has seemed very heavy-handed in trying to assign suspicion, to the extent that it seems potentially like a ploy. Zinger's list is an extremely dubious claim (though I would like him to answer dor it in person) and does not strike me as legitimate.

...and not lynch until we have more information.

But I'm not sure if that's optimal with an unknown player composition.

I am late to the party, but better late than never.

In traditional Dethy there would be four cop sanities.

We're not exactly in a traditional setting. The four sanities may exist, but there is room for other things entirely (patterned results (+/- or -/+ for example) or random ones -- if Dusky's situation is an indication). And that's not even touching on what Rag mentioned (Krampus ability, whether it exists or not).


@Dark:

There were two deaths. Given the amount of people in this game, and with it being "Dethy" -esque, we're probably dealing with an empowered Krampus that can kill twice. That or there are multiple scum (though I'd question this being a Dethy then).

Either way, one of those results also had a naughty on someone else (Sky's first result on Neon). At the very least, given how Neon and Arrgh talked, they could likely target unlike Dusky seemingly having random results.

I would say the aggression from Mongoose towards Sky is definitely aggro. Enough so that I doubt he'd do that intentionally only to draw attention onto himself.

And as for Zinger's NLP, or lack thereof, I'd be in serious doubt of him having a list as he's claimed; however, he could be lying as town as well. Of the two I'd say Zinger's lack of a NLP combined with his claim of a list is more sus than Mongoose and his aggression.

I agree with that.