I feel like if we do not act today on well-reasoned information, we are giving undue time to JDCD to further manipulate results. Lynch me if you must, but don't sacrifice the game to indolence, folks.

Fair enough.

Vote: Tevish

As much as I'd prefer CL go down, I respect taking me up on my offer.

in just over 1 hour, it looks like tevish might be lynched.

deadline approaching.

Tevish has been Lynched. We won't be having a happy Hanukkah this year.

Votes against: CL, Monster

You've got until noon EST tomorrow to deliver your night actions.

Living Players:

1. JD
2. CL
3. Argh
4. monster
   Tevish
   KoD

Day 3. No deaths last Night, surprisingly.

There are four of you left. Can you find and stop JD's Christmas Dethy before he or she decks your halls for good? We'll find out!

Deadline is December 30th at 12:01 PM Eastern. You can end the Day early if y'all agree.

I think I have my play for today.

Night 0 I got culted by JD's Christmas Dethy. My new win condition is to help JD's Christmas Dethy win.

I do believe with 4 players left alive, if JD's Christmas Dethy wants to come forward and identify themselves, together the two of us can overpower the vote and help you win.

So, that's a thing.

How can 2 players form a majority, M0nster?

Two players could prevent a majority from forming, thus preventing either of them from being lynched.

I trust JD fully at this point, so CL, if you are innocent, then Monster is just playing a massive bluff here. Either way, if Monster is telling the truth, town cannot hope to lynch Christmas Dethy. Thus, the only hope we have is that Monster is lying Christmas Dethy.

Vote: Monster

What he said.

Vote: Argh

Bwahahaha
Vote: Aaarrrgh

Well, that absolutely sucks.

unvote; vote:CL

At this point, our only hope is that monster's cultification somehow affected their vote. Which presumably it does, because otherwise the game should already be over.

It's a fake culting so it probably won't. The motions will have to be followed through. Mislynch will have to happen today, a kill tonight. Stalemate tomorrow. Victory the next night. The motions are only stoppable by one player at this point and that's probably semi unlikely. So yeah.

Vote: CL

How do you know it's fake? I mean, obviously something is wrong considering the fact that the game should be over if this was an actual stalemate. But there's no telling what the way out of the stalemate actually is at this point, right?

Because I was fake culted last night. With a 3 on 1 there's no way the game doesn't end without shenanigans. Turning to the OP we are told that JDCD's abilities are there to confound us into lynching the wrong holiday. It's spelled out pretty plain if you're looking for the answers.

Oh, that makes perfect sense. Monster, are you following this?

@Zinger
So the cult can't be real or the game would already be over. Is this logic proved by a way the rules work?

JD's argument makes sense. I only skimmed the rules, but it does seem like "abilities designed to confound and trick us into lynching the wrong person" is more likely to be a fake culting than a real one...

Add to that the fact that JD is claiming to have been culted last Night... Nobody died, so it seems likely. And if both JD AND I have been culted, the game should be over, yeah? Unless this is a lie from JD to try and get me to switch my vote...

CL is obviously JD's Christmas Dethy. So the only deciding factor now is whether or not I believe my win con has been changed. Hmm...

Unvote

So you figured out I'm Dethy.
But it doesnt prove Im the one who culted you. This story of that the mod told them a cult attemp failed on them. Mods typically don't report failed cult attempts. The story's sounds unlikely and is full of wifom bastrardy.