I maintain, given the information we had YESTERDAY and not TODAY that it was the correct decision at the time, yes.

Do we know better today? Sure! But hindsight is 20/20, and tevish maintains he knew better yesterday. He didn't, but maintains he did, which is suspicious. That's the point.

I do find Aaarrrgh suspect, but I always find Aaarrrgh suspect, so I can't trust my analytical or intuitive instincts when he is involved. I am willing to support his lynch if and only if some number of players with different in-game perspectives agree that he is the candidate.

Otherwise, I'm inclined towards Exlight. His apparently contradictory role claims and his effective admission of non-towniness are problematic. Though it is prudent to note that his basic claim of fluid alignment is technically within the rule-set (however, he cannot be formally self).

I also find it kind of bizarre that we aren't cross-examining Monster.


I am actually inclined to agree in principle (i.e. that probabilistic decisions are correct or not independent of their results), even if I disagree with the actual decision. So, carry on.

Too many of us voted for Rag to single out for only that behavior.

Broke.


My pinky was cut off.

So savage.


Amber has yet to offer anything insightful.

Well well well.

It seems we have a scum team of Amber, Goose, and Ex.

You are more than welcome to cross-examine me yourself instead of shoving vague, noncommittal, accusatory fingers (severed or otherwise) my direction.

This is textbook mafia scumslinging 101.


I resent that. I am too a savage. Don't let my cute avatar fool you.

I'm not the particular savage who severed your pinky, but that doesn't mean I don't on occasion live up to my name.


Well, see, there's the proof it wasn't me. If I had done it, I would have bitten your pinky off, not cut it off. Because I'm a savage.

myself in case I had to make any promises today

Ooooooooooo


Also, yeah, you're totes a "monster" ha ha.







Preview Edit:

@Ex:

Yeah, sure. How do you feel about being lynched today?

I never claimed to be a roleblocker; it prevents someone from having their promises forcibly broken. It prevents disruption, not cause them.

And I have the kill thing while I don’t pick an alignment, yea. Activates on nightkill and on last one in my wagon, not hammer. I’m assuming it’s to punish people for going after someone who isn’t even a real player.

Care to promise?

lol cute
same as yesterday, if you’re the last one in my wagon that will make me happy k thanks

I already promised yesterday and I stand by that.

Me self targeting shouldn’t make stuff I say any more credible if that’s your logic. It prevents mechanical roles from breaking promises, if me or my target were to willingly break them they’d still be punished accordingly.

I was going to dig through your promises, but you know what? Why bother? The end result would be to push a lynch on you anyway.

I can do that without all that effort.



@Everyone else: At your earliest convenience, before deadline, please vote Ex.

I promise to place my vote on Ex last, provided someone doesn't outvote me near deadline (at which point, and still part of the promise, I will unvote and revote Ex with the full intent to be the last vote on Ex).


I'm willing to die to solve you. There is no victory to be had for you.

Hardly. It was my first Day 2 post after a weekend hiatus. Obviously, given the Day 1 double-doctor claim and the subsequent death of an actual doctor, I am entitled to a certain measure of surprise that, over three pages of discussion, nobody cared to examine the narrative that mafia somehow has two kills and that you are de facto 'confirmed' by Rag's demise.

In particular, given that Dusky was third party, and given as well that KoD's pinky was cut off, we ought to consider that her death might have been triggered by the breaking of the promise she made with KoD rather a second scum kill. (Side notes: this implicates Ex a bit, as he has been using the supposed "second kill" as a crutch for why we shouldn't kill him. It also somewhat exculpates the inactive players in the sense that we'd expect scum to not want to examine these facts, so the lack of discussion thus far implies a higher than random distribution of scum among active players).

Which is not to say that you aren't a doctor. But we ought to at least consider the facts.

My fingers are also firmly attached.

My hero.

Given my position on Ex, I am willing to honor KoD's sacrifice.

Vote:Exlight

Minds more brilliant than myself can figure out who the mafia are once you are out of the way. Of that I have no doubt. But you, with the danger you pose and the distraction that you are, cannot be allowed to live any further. At the very least, I know you'd be willing to stab town in the back as I've seen the admission once.

I think the next vote on Ex is majority. Be careful, friends.

I think Tevish is on Ex. I know Arrgh is. You would make three.

I'm not sure if there are others on him aside from you three.

If Ex is L-1, then I am formally announcing intent to hammer him within the next 24 hours.

You have all been notified.

It's Tevish, amber, ME, and Sky right now for 4 votes (by my count, which may be inaccurate).