Here is an itemized list of thirty reasons why you're scum this game:

1. Play style -

Your play style is concretely that of a deep wolf. You take the safe path to appear as town to the rest of the town in the game (as evidenced by last game). This is compounded by the tools you use which I'll talk about later. Because you choose this particular path, it makes assessing you difficult without a healthy dose of skepticism (read: heavy paranoia on my part) in order to actually read you. For the most part, a lot of the players here are not on my level of paranoia when it comes to some players (read: some) which is partially why you're able to go undetected for so long. Some players, like Zinger, can certainly sniff you out though when you off them it makes it that much harder to nail you. Do note that, as far as a previous post of yours wrt to this goes, leaving you alive till that much later in the game is not so much a solution to finding out if you are scum as opposed to a dangerous position to put ourselves into as, by then, it may be too late.

2. Your tools -

As previously brought up, your particular tools are, naturally, your masterful reasoning and logic. If, and this is a not an if as far as this game is concerned, you are town, then your tools would certainly be well adept at susing out the scum; however, as scum, your tools only serve to undermine all of our efforts. For example, refer back to your previous "bargain" about leaving you alive, and working with you, until such point where you're still alive later in the game. Such reasoning serves only to help position yourself as close to LyLo as you can possibly get without much suspicion bein on you. And, as I have mentioned, it may be too late by that point to get at you. Why? I'll leave that for another point which, I believe, plays well into your play style. Suffice it to say, your tools are useful as town, no doubt. As scum? They are incredibly indispensable. This is why you trying to reason with me earlier about working with you comes off as you being sus. After all, I was vocal last game about you guys. Yet I was made the nk target (whether by you or not hardly matters).

3. Night killing active targets -

As mentioned above, this plays into your play style. It's one thing for you to fool town as a deep cover wolf with the tools you have availed yourself of. You're also keen of mind as far as your strategy goes. After all, killing off active players to take control of a rather inactive town? A tried, true, and safe method of game play. Fitting for someone who plays the deep cover, wouldn't you say? Matter of fact if you look back at the guide you were kind enough to post, you should notice something extremely glaring in it. You have yourself listed as killing a random lurker, or Monster possibly. That is absurd to say the least. You are most definitely capable of killing active players to remove them as a threat. It's safe. It fits. Compared with Monster who plays savagely, I'd say this is right up your ally in every respect. So already you've put forth false information that makes you even more sus than before. More so that I may have to move my vote from Arrgh onto you because why not?

4. Your persona -

This is also telling of how scummy you are. Refer to how you establish yourself as a master (which you certainly are). You're making it known to everyone. Not just me. What does that tell me? That you're trying to establish dominance as an authority figure from which you can, possibly, make plays with weight behind them (like saying pursue you later and work with you for now to catch scum -- despite being scum yourself). Given your play style, this helps provide a cushion to you as well. Not only are you playing it safe as a deep cover wolf with useful reasoning and logic, you're also inserting yourself as an important figure. One that town would regret not having around. That fits the narrative rather well, and it is yet another reason why you are scum.

5. Unattended town- -

This connects with the third point. That is to say, in killing active town targets, you leave behind inactive town. Last game is a good indication of what happens when you don't have active town, and if you are left to take charge of such town, you'll drive them, intentionally, off a cliff. So you moving to insert yourself as an important town figure only underscores how dangerously scummy you are when, given how you approach the game, you'll only take advantage of those players not willing to step it up a notch.

6. Dusky -

Given your desire to honor the office of the Terisian Mayor, Dusky can't be trusted to be objective where you're concerned. You will, likely, utilize your honor for that office in such a way that it causes Dusky to reciprocate the honor which may cause her to misread you and backstab me, thus letting me down into my grave again. As such, I have to be wary of Dusky by extension because of you, and that makes you suspect given this issue. It is likely Dusky may have to be removed into order to objectively pursue you. That is something I am prepared to do if it is absolutely necessary in order to sus you out properly.

7. Killing Dusky -

Do you know how scummy this makes you? Dusky is a cinnamon bun, as I'm sure you'll agree, and having to remove her to get at you is dastardly; however, the greater good must be pursued despite the potential unintended future casualty. Thus, in order to prevent this, your removal becomes increasingly necessary in order to advert such scummy conditions.

8. Teamwork -

Your brand of teamwork, as scum, is vile in so much as you're the kind who pulls the strings. This leads to masterful manipulation of not only town, but any scum partners you may have. Such is the case with Monster; however, since we are, more than likely, looking at only one scum (read: you), there is not much danger of you manipulating any teammates you may not have (unless of course you do have a teammate in which case yeah, you are extremely dangerous).

9. Addendum to tools -

It should be noted that you have another skill that definitely shines as scum: Deception. Unlike Arrgh and Zinger, you're certainly not above using lies to further manipulate people towards your ends. That furthers how deadly, as scum, you are. You can, and will, utilize this tool towards the late game to secure a victory for yourself. That is something that can, and will, be prevented via removing you early.

10. Pinky Promise Mafia -

You never made a pinky promise (that put you at risk). That makes you a special type of evil. Not the kind that will savagely remove someone's pinkies, but the kind that sees no use for such promises. Like, how dare you be that scummy.

11. Pinky Promise Mafia Addendum -

You were allied to someone who savagely removed my pinkies. How. Dare. You.

12.The Ivory Tower -

I won't forget how hard you made me work to try and better myself to beat Nyphe. But you know what? You totally didn't give me the proper tools to best Nyphe which lead to me receiving a thrashing. Do you know how much that hurt? Like, oof. That's how much. All these years, and I haven't forgotten. And yet you have the audacity to still act as my master? Like, double oof. Oof so much that I can see just how much that authority position matters in terms of being scum.

Note: It's been a long time, but I do remember certain points that left an impression. My time as your student certainly left an impression.

13. JD -

I've got nothing against JD. Even if JD gets me killed. No, I include JD as a reason here because I fear that you will attempt to be evil with your skill set towards JD, and the thought of it makes me want to start a crusade now. To prevent it. Like, more so than preventing Dusky's death. I have no doubt in my mind that JD can and will negate whatever vile schemes you come up with, but what kind of husbando would I be if I wasn't proactive against you in the first place? A horrible kind, that's what.

14. Profile -

You're a chocobo. Chocobos are not scummy; however, did you whark when you appeared in here? No. Ergo, you're sus for being a "chocobo". I'm on to your games of deception and illusion.

15. KoD Must Die Mafia -

Since I brought up Pinky Promise, I figured it was worth bringing up KoD Must Die as another study in your profile (the non-chocobo kind). In that game you were not a rebel. Instead, you utilized your reasoning fairly well, and were quite the voice in terms of guiding people. Here, you're taking a different position (read: asserting yourself as a master). This is telling in some fashion. One that I believe showcases your scum side.