Vote: Monster


I sincerely doubt I'll be up in time to revoke this vote if Monster changes his mind. If he wants to save himself, well, he'll have to get a tie going. Otherwise, urrrrghkkk!

Monster just stated that her preferred pronouns are she/her. And I don't think the D1 lynch is warranted. There is no reason not to let the game go to D2 with sus on monster. Heck, if the claim is true, then the restriction might be lifted tomorrow for all we know.

Also, CL sus for telling monster not to share info, even though that might get monster lynched.

unvote. Vote: KoD

We are all standoff like now. Nobody should be placing votes from here.

That seems reasonable. I am willing to soft commit to make anyone who votes now tomorrow's lynch (I'm only soft committing because there might be a fringe case where there is a legitimate reason to vote. Not counting on it though).

That's the end of Day 1. Nobody has been Lynched.

votes
Monster (1): KoD
JD (1): Monster
KoD (1): JD

Night 1 will last for 24 hours (until 1PM EST Christmas Day), or until all actions are in.

IT'S TIME TO DECK KINGOFDOMINARIA'S HALLS... PERMANENTLY!

Y'all wake up to a wonderful Christmas morning. All of you except KoD who is very dead. Guess we won't be celebrating Kwanzaa this year.

It is now Day 2. Day 2 will last until 12:01 PM Eastern time on Sunday the 27th unless all y'all unanimously agree to end the Day early.

It's definitely CL.

I investigated myself and received that I am none other than Christmas Dethy. This means that one of two things is true

1) I am Random
2) I am Insane, and CL is Christmas Dethy

The game started 5-1. Right now it is 4-1. If we lynch today, we can lynch again tomorrow in LyLo

Since I believe there is a 50% chance CL is Christmas Dethy based on my results alone, I see no reason to not banish him to the shadow realm.

VOTE: CL

EBWOP: That's from my perspective. Others may believe me to be Christmas Dethy instead, but I seen no reason to not act.

Remember that there can be manipulation afoot.

I investigated CL and was told he is JD's Christmas Dethy.

That means from my perspective there are four options:
1. Tevish is Christmas Dethy.
2. CL is Christmas Dethy.
3. I am random.
4. Results have been tampered with.

4 would be hard to prove right now (I don't have the time and energy to make deep analysis today).

3 is moot, because combined with Tevish's results, it still brings us to the point where it has to be Tevish or CL. I'm not ready to commit to anything yet, though.

My officially results are double negative. In other news I'm currently working under the theory that monster is amber and KoD just got comeuppance.

I investigated tevish and got Not Chistmas Dethy.

Well its not me so....
I'll voting tevish unless he wants to unvote

Vote: Tevish

I really don't know what's going on in this game.

I'll say I am definitely not Sane, nor Naive.

If I am Insane, CL and I are on the same team.

I could be Paranoid or Random, I suppose.

Monster, are you still not able to claim your results?

We can derive from that that Monster has Guilty results on himself and CL.

Oh. Yeah, that makes sense.

KoD investigated himself (Innocent) and died. He was either Sane, Naive, or Random
Aaarrrgh investigated me (Innocent) and CL (Guilty). He is either Sane, Insane, or Random
Monster can be assumed to have investigated himself or CL, both Guilty. This makes him Paranoid, Insane, or Random
I investigated CL (Innocent) and Myself (Guilty). I can only be Insane or Random
JD investigated Monster (Innocent) and Someone Else (Innocent). He can be Naive, Random, or Sane
CL investigated KoD (Guilty) and myself (Innocent). He can be Insane or Random

Monster is the only player who has recieved only Guilty results. This means he MUST be Paranoid, and is therefore Not Scum.

Monster's preferred pronouns are she/her.

Other than that, your analysis seems mostly correct. On the assumption that scum cannot kill and use other abilities at the same time, and Monster claims to have been hit with an ability N0, it seems the only possibilities left are either a bluffing scum monster who manipulated someone's results N0, or it's either Tevish or CL.

This is pretty much a troll game so that's expected. I have my suspicions that JDCD's win con might be something like get a player mislynched. Or maybe just an additional perk to the role or something.