He's happy to do lies of omission, though.

For example, everyone might lose on day 8, not just scum.

It's worth considering.

However, I will make an exception in this specific case to tell you that not everyone will lose on Day 8, but the Mafia most certainly will if they don't find a way to either end me (a difficult thing to do for sure) or end the game before then (less difficult, presumably)

Chill out.

I never lie.

Why would the first player who gets it be protected?

The town will always kill people with no evidence, that's how mafia works.

How is trying to get discussion going by suggesting that you be picked for something that literally every player in the game should want unless they distrust the skeleton's words a bad thing? Do you suggest no one vote to lynch anyone either because we haven't properly discussed who is scummy yet?


Every second I see ExLight's reasoning at work I feel myself losing intelligence. That's what bothers me.

My brain is going to melt like ice cream that's been left out in the sun for too long.

I'm counting down to the deadline as given by the mod, that's all. The lynch deadline, to be specific; CS deadline was 24 hours earlier. I might be 1 hour off thanks to Daylight Savings Time


@KoD: I'm not particularly wedded (pun intended) to voting Funnier towards the Crystal Skeleton date, but I wanted a competing CS-Wagon to Rubik's and knew funnier had at least one vote. Plus, he hadn't really tripped any scummy feelings for me. Far too early to say he really "reads as town" especially when I don't know his playstyle, but close enough for present CS-voting needs

~~~

Having quickly read over the last few pages, I'm very tempted to jump on the HW wagon. It honestly baffles me that someone in an online mafia game, which is nothing but reading, and is best solved by careful reading, would voice a disinterest in reading and hostility to writing.

Players should explain their reads and their reasoning in detail. That way, we can go back and analyze those details in the light of new developments. Single sentence soundbite posts aren't nearly as useful for town because they don't give us half as much insignt into the thoughts and feelings of the poster involved. They don't cause scum to have to find a plausible excuse for their behavior, don't give us material for cross-examination, don't allow us to find half as many contradictions or fallacies... you get the idea. They're better than lurking, but more should be encouraged, not discouraged.

3 days, 23 hours, 57 minutes remain

Weighing in, I have to agree that not wanting to read in a Mafia game is definitely not a productive mindset at all. I don't mind policy lynching someone with that mindset since it can only be detrimental for Town. So HW could end up getting my vote today unless they put more effort in. The Day has only just begun afterall.

Because KoD is protecting Rubik.

And lmao did you remove your vote on me to OMGUS, KoD? c’mon fite me

OK, first time through I missed Minish's post.



There is an absolute fallacy in this thinking, and it is this: an Innocent Child is a role that is publicly confirmed to be town. By the time you posted, we had been told directly that Aaarrrgh's alignment was NOT mod-confirmed.

UNVOTE; VOTE: Minish
4 days, 22 hours, 29 minutes remain

HW knows better. Using me as an excuse to not read is not excusable.

I am not an excuse.

@ExLight:

I don't agree with anything you're saying.

Specifically, if you keep everything lined up when addressing thoughts, I'm following Rubik wrt to you because you jumping him about his role was scummy. As far as Rubik wanting the CS to date him, that progression, for me, is at a point where Rubik comes off more as townie to me than as scummy (especially if we're using you as the bar for scummy if you know what I mean). If you think Rubik is scum (which I assume would revolve around his role as that is what you attacked him over) that's your thing. Not mine.


@funnier:

What exactly are you asking me with that first thought? Because my thought on Minish revolves around that particular post Minish made, as I've already stated. Whether or not Minish is truly an IC is something for another time as there is nothing else to go on (indeed if anything even happens as, again, it was a knee-jerk reaction to her post).

If other people nominate me for the CS, that's one thing. Me putting myself out there is another. My CS vote is already on JD though (and truly he deserves it anyway).

Duly noted.


Preview Edit:

@ExLight:

Wouldn't it be OMGUS if he voted me, then I voted him in response? Because that's not what happened. You'd know that from reading the posts.

ngl I’m kinda cocky from my last win
flawlessly beatin all those veterans
good stuff


Unvote CS

“I don’t have any concrete reasons”, “curious if my role could have some type of affect”
:glare:

if you explain yourself a lil’ more I might vote you

Freddeh please post, I'm planning to sheep your vote.

Now that I think about it, sheeping PK is fine too
Oh wait, I'm already sheeping PK, nice.

Ex you’re such a moron

Why aren't you voting there if youre very tempted

Arrogance makes me mad, probably.

We like to create some sort of mechanic to chew on d1 sometimes which makes it a lot easier to start reading people.

I'm not sure why you think I'd try to be the first person to persue the CS as scum when any player regardless of alignment allegedly benefits from it. Scum benefits from staying out of the spotlight more than taking it, probably.

I think Rubik isn't a great lynch. Sure everyone seeing him at night isn't exactly AI, but I feel like he stands out so much because of that an everything that if he is scum it will become apparent. But I just feel he's town which is weird because he's always scum. Haha.


Also @Rubik, can you tell me anything about Tevish, Naga, and Hello World regarding meta? Or anything you think would be important? Do any of those 3 pique your interest in any way so far?