Aamir Gives to… Sundar Elarion

Alessa Rehn Gives to… Syl

Aloise Hartley Gives to… The Liar

Amah al-Hazid Gives to… Larasa Fareth

Antine Gives to… Daneera

Aria Gives to… Tryst

Asher Gives to… Erik Sylvaine

Beryl Gives to… Raiker Venn

Blink Gives to… Kahr-ret-Taris

Cara Gives to… Jade

Chardis Gives to… Aamir

Clade Gives to… Ygraine of Segovia

Daneera Gives to… Clade

Denner Fabellian Gives to… "I"

Donagut Gives to… Huinn

The Duchess Gives to… Vasilias

Ellia the Endbringer Gives to… Pendulum

Erik Sylvaine Gives to… Aria

Fisco Vane Gives to… The Shifter

Gruff Gives to… Beryl

Huinn Gives to… Jinsen

"I" Gives to… Gruff

Illarion Vale Gives to… Nasperge

Jackie DeCoeur Gives to… Rishima

Jinsen Gives to… Amah al-Hazid

Kahr-ret-Taris Gives to… Penelophine

Kimberley Talon Gives to… Alessa Rehn

Kirsh Gives to… Jackie DeCoeur

Larasa Fareth Gives to… Lia Xin

Morgan of Voor Gives to… Asher

The Liar Gives to… Chardis

Lia Xin Gives to… Lourima Viiran

Lourima Viiran Gives to… Lukas Harran

Lukas Harran Gives to… Fisco Vane

Maral Gives to… Zhiran

Mari Gwynn Gives to… Donagut

Nasperge Gives to… Kirsh

Pendulum Gives to… Mari Gwynn

Penelophine Gives to… Antine

Raef Gives to… Aloise Hartley

Raiker Venn Gives to… Morgan of Voor

Raleris Gives to… Renn Winmoore

Jade Gives to… Kimberley Talon

Renn Winmoore Gives to… Raleris

Rishima Gives to… Maral

Sava Pith Gives to… Raef

The Shifter Gives to… The Duchess

Sundar Elarion Gives to… Ellia the Endbringer

Syl Gives to… Illarion Vale

Tryst Gives to… Cara

Vasilias Gives to… Denner Fabellian

Ygraine of Segovia Gives to… Blink

Zhiran Gives to… Sava Pith

Beryl gets Raiker a rave review
Clade gets Ygraine a lovely, forested Segovia full of monsters to hunt.
Ellia gets Pendulum some extra limb grafts
Jackie gets Rishima a six-pack of bullets, delivered via gun.
Pendulum gets Mari a cure for depresson *shudder*
Raiker gets Morgan a starring role
Syl gets Illarion Marina's mangled corpse

Amah gets Larasa A Treatise on Elements, Elementals, and the Uses Thereof
Clade gets Ygraine a bonsai world-tree sapling (About Ygraine's height)
Gruff gets Beryl a particularly shiny piece of flint
Larasa gets Lia a brush and an Aether map to Shang Rasoul
Morgan gets Asher some of the writings of Varrignan (Scribed from memory), all the better to summon some really intense nightmares.

Aloise gives The Liar a basket of soaps and bath salts. (hint hint)

I like (both) of Tevish's suggestions for Clade giving stuff to Ygraine, so there's that.

Daneera gives Clade a Baloth. They're so cuddly!

Ellia gives Pendulum ETERNAL TORMENT a brand new set of surgical equipment.

Fisco gives the Shifter a fruitcake.

Huinn gives Jinsen a dead rat. It's the thought that counts.

Jinsen gives Amah The Winding Path, an anthology of Kamigawan poetry.

Kimberley gives Alessa a bottle of wine and a box of chocolates.

The Liar gives Chardis Daneera's exact location. Upon arrival, a bucket of water falls on Chardis' head.

(AHAHAHAHA) Lukas gives Fisco a treatise on the dangers of demonspawn.

Pendulum offers Mari Gwynn "a more permanent alternative for form changing magic." She politely declines.

(Snort) Raef gives Aloise a sword, because she "should be able to defend herself". She insists that it's a very pretty sword and keeps it on a stand in her room where it can reflect the sunlight.

Jade gives Kimberley a dream catcher.

Sava Pith gives Raef three rounds on her and an arm wrestling match. (Raef wins, but Sava drinks him under the table.)

Zhiran gives Sava a long look and a ring that quiets the voices in her head.

Aamir gives Sundar Elarion a mirror. From one half-elf planeswalker to another...

Antine gives Daneera a great big hug. Then he gives her another one.

Chardis gives Aamir a Cybernetic War Flamingo.

Donagut gives Huinn...a wide berth. That guy's nuts.

Lia Xin gives Lourima Viiran some serious paranoia. "There's a reason she's not talking to me!"

Ygraine gives to Blink...the eye of a needle?

Alessa gets Syl a nice dress... from her own closet.
The Duchess gives Vasilias a pair of house slippers and a thinly veiled card mocking him for never leaving his room.
Gruff gives Beryl a fine assortment of bugs. Juicy ones. He worked very hard to collect them, stayed up all night.
Huinn gives Jensen a knife. Left in his pillow with no explanation.
Raef gives Aloise a doll he had really meant to give his sister, but the holidays came so suddenly and he's quite embarrassed.
Raiker Venn gives Morgan a lovely poem about two star crossed lovers.
Renn gives Raleris peace of mind by being lucid for a bit around him.
Rishima gives Maral exotic oils and silk.
The Shifter gives the Duchess the finger. She's not sure who it belongs to....
Tryst gives Cara a lovely time share if she'd just sign on the line....

...Aria gives Tryst a book of fairy tales to read to her daughter.

...Beryl gives Raiker Venn a discreet, manly cologne that she mixed in her shop.

...Gale gives herself the gift of a night spent high up in the riggings, feeling the wind in her hair.

...Gruff gives Beryl his best poking stick. For poking.

...Jackie gives Rishima a very fetching black serape, with wing-holes cut out in the back.

...Kirsh gives Jackie a new pair of dancing boots.

...Tryst gives Cara a suspiciously-large sack filled with powdered devilkin teeth -- very useful stuff, given the right application.

Clearly in:
1. Aloise
2. The firewalker
3. Alessa
4. Nasperge
5. Hepthia

Iffy, for various reasons:
1. Fisco (leaning to yes, but his motives are unclear)
2. Diana (doesn't have any discernable emotional reaction, but she was at least kind of looking out for Beryl)
3. Moira's reflection (not technically a person?)
4. Lys (we never see them interact on-screen, but it's pretty clear that they do meet off-screen, and that Lys is kind to her)

Considering his probably usual Modus Operandi, you could argue the Shifter was pretty nice...

Let's check back in on that assessment in a little while...